Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Home Sport Rugby World Cup

Rugby World Cup: Schmidt must identify Ireland's best team and use it

By Tony Ward

Published 15/09/2015

'I wouldn’t write off Tommy Bowe, but based on the evidence of the warm-up games, I would go with Dave Kearney and Simon Zebo on the wings'
'I wouldn’t write off Tommy Bowe, but based on the evidence of the warm-up games, I would go with Dave Kearney and Simon Zebo on the wings'
Class: Iain Henderson has proved he is ready to start

With just three days to go to the big kick-off, Irish fans holds their breath in the hope that the real Ireland, the Six Nations champions, will finally stand up.

I'm as confused as anyone. I don't believe we deliberately under-performed in the final two warm-up games, but equally I have little doubt that some of our attacking moves have been kept under wraps.

England World Cup winner Ben Kay has weighed in, saying he is "convinced the Irish have slowed their preparations during the warm-up games" and he is right.

But I feel he is off the mark in claiming that there is a strategy aimed at peaking towards the climax of the Pool, specifically the big one against the French in the Millennium Stadium on October 11.

That would be the dream scenario, but such luxuries don't exist in a World Cup.

Ireland have been gifted the ideal draw, but intensity doesn't come with a switch. That's something the All Blacks preach: you can't turn on and off your intensity depending on who you are playing. It has to be there all the time.

Ireland's warm-up series has gone better than it did in 2007, but it has been mixed.

Our best performance was against the Welsh at Cardiff in the opener.

We were average against the Scots and things went downhill in the two games after that. Losing those final matches doesn't matters, but underperforming does - it chips away at the confidence within a squad.

However, he warm-ups were useful in providing much-needed game-time and Ireland came through the four matches relatively unscathed, save for the injury to Tommy O'Donnell - contrast that with the two key injuries the Welsh suffered.

But I'm not sure what Joe Schmidt can have learned from the four matches. If anything, they provided more questions than answers.

Try these:

What is our best back three?

Who can supply the Brian O'Driscoll spark?

What is the best midfield combination?

Is Paddy Jackson or Ian Madigan the better out-half cover for Johnny Sexton?

Who is the third loosehead in the squad and will Cian Healy establish match fitness?

Devin Toner or Iain Henderson to pack down alongside Paul O'Connell?

Is Chris Henry worth his place in the search for a different back-row dynamic entirely?

Are we capable of playing the type of off-loading game all but guaranteed by the southern hemisphere sides in the coming weeks?

Republic of Ireland football manager Martin O'Neill is often criticised for not knowing his best XI; right now, can we be sure Schmidt knows his run-on Ireland XV?

Maybe that is no bad thing, but if I were in charge and looking to peak for the France game, my aim would be to get my best XV on the field early.

Of course, that best XV might change over the next few weeks, but I would hold nothing back against Canada in Cardiff and put out the team that I would field if we were playing France.

As back-to-back Six Nations champions, I would look to make a World Cup statement right from the off.

The alternative is to mix and match in the opening two games, thereby kicking the can of uncertainty further down the road.

The Romanian match offers room for manoeuvre and should be treated as such, providing we deliver the same level of intensity irrespective of some changed personnel. It must not be seen as an opportunity to give everyone involved a run.

The key decisions for Schmidt are the back three, loosehead and lock.

I wouldn't write off Tommy Bowe (pictured), but based on the evidence of the warm-up games, I would go with Dave Kearney and Simon Zebo on the wings.

Henderson gets my vote ahead of Toner in the engine room and I would stick with Jack McGrath at loosehead, with Cian Healy on the bench.

Belfast Telegraph

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph