Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Home Sport Rugby World Cup

World Cup Rugby: Should Joe Schmidt play his strongest side against the Canadians?

Published 16/09/2015

Full stretch: The Ireland squad warm-up at Carton House ahead of travelling to the World Cup
Full stretch: The Ireland squad warm-up at Carton House ahead of travelling to the World Cup

Ruaidhri O'Connor says Yes: Joe Schmidt is an assiduous reader of all things written about his Ireland team, so when he leafed through his cuttings on Monday morning he would have come across Rory Best's assessment of the 2007 World Cup.

Along with Paul O'Connell and Eoin Reddan, the hooker is one of three veterans of that tournament still in the squad, while forwards coach Simon Easterby was also involved in the disastrous events in France.

Best's assertion that the players were wrapped in cotton wool for too long rang true and is a cautionary tale going into this opening game against Canada.

Ranked 19th in the world, Ireland's opponents are one of the weakest in this year's competition, but the pool favourites still need to gel on the field and in the heat of battle despite the risk of injury.

Unlike the southern hemisphere giants who have been playing competitive rugby almost non-stop since February, the European sides have had the summer off and, while Schmidt's team played one more warm-up game than most, there are still players who need game-time.

The coach rotated throughout the warm-ups and, apart from Rob Kearney and the injured Cian Healy, they have each featured in two games so far.


Those games are already fading into memory and, by the time Ireland take on France on October 11, they'll be long forgotten.

At that stage, the important thing is that the starting team have clicked and are in the groove as they look to book the more advantageous quarter-final.

Training can only get you so far and combinations will only gel when playing games.

Canada are a limited opponent, but the intensity they bring should cause the Six Nations champions the kind of problems that can only bring them on.

There is also the Cardiff factor. Ireland will be back at the Millennium Stadium in four weeks' time and, with the roof set to be closed on both occasions, Saturday allows them the chance to experience the arena at its loudest.

It might sound like a small thing, but listen to Schmidt talk about the "marginal gains" and you can see why he'd be keen for his front-liners to have fresh experience of the noise levels, heat and, perhaps crucially, condensation that accompany a big game in the Welsh capital when the roof is shut.

Most importantly, this is about momentum.

While he is likely to rotate his squad before the week two meeting with Romania, fielding the strongest possible side this Saturday will allow Schmidt's team to set the tone for the games to come.

All week, the mantra from Ireland will be that they are taking things week by week and not looking beyond Kieran Crowley's Canada.

By doing so, they hope to generate momentum to take into the steps up in class in weeks three and four against Italy and France.

They are expected to win big in their first two games and, while doing so won't cause any tremors around the tournament, it would give Ireland a strong base from which to work and allow them to grow into the competition as others with more demanding schedules seek to hit the ground running now.

Still, while Ireland may not want to show their hand, there is a need to be at full pitch when it comes to the business end of the pool stages and that's not going to happen if the main players are not involved in the early rounds.

Sure, there's a risk of injury, but it's one Ireland have to take if they are to succeed at this World Cup. They can only be kept on the leash so long.

The World Cup is here and the best players need to get up to speed right away by playing together as much as possible.

Cian Tracey says No

While I wouldn't be inclined to play two completely different XVs in the opening couple of games, there is certainly an argument to be made for Joe Schmidt to select a mix and match of front-line and fringe players against Canada.

The draw has been kind to Ireland in that they meet the two 'weaker' nations before the quality is ramped up against Italy and France.

Schmidt has spent the last two years developing an Irish squad that is arguably heading into a World Cup in the strongest ever position.

Granted, the last time that was said (2007), Ireland crashed and burned but throughout that pool campaign, there was very little rotation in the starting XV.

Ireland have rarely been afforded the luxury of having such strength in depth and they should make the most of that. Canada won't roll over but nevertheless, Ireland are vastly superior and can build momentum by getting off to a winning start without starting the same XV that will line out against Italy and France.

All summer, Schmidt has spoken about the importance of peaking at the right time and he will have left his players with no doubt that there is no room for complacency.

In the last two World Cups, Ireland have began by playing one of the two lesser teams. In 2007, an unconvincing 32-17 win over Namibia hardly sent out a warning while four years later, they stuttered past USA 22-10.

On both occasions, Ireland lined out with an almost full-strength team but eventually came unstuck later in the tournament.

There is a different feel surrounding Schmidt's team. Going into the World Cup as back-to-back Six Nations champions means that teams will be targeting Ireland but the Kiwi's players know what it takes to win.

Jack McGrath remains in pole position to start and given that Schmidt only brought two specialised loosehead props and indeed Cian Healy's need for game time, he should be considered for a start.

The Ireland coach knows what McGrath is capable of and against a Romanian side that will target the set-piece, he should be rested.

Tadhg Furlong has been brought as cover for both sides of the scrum and could also do with minutes at loosehead.

There is a similar argument to be made at scrum-half. Conor Murray has completed his return to play protocols but had he suffered concussion in a pool game as opposed to a warm-up, Ian Madigan would be needed to cover.

We have yet to see Madigan get a run at scrum-half and with just two No.9s in the squad, it is important to give him game-time there if the unthinkable comes to pass.

Canada are likely to be a stubborn unit to break down but Ireland have enough quality to do it without ultimately having to name their first-choice starting XV.

Perhaps tellingly, Ireland manager Mick Kearney spoke earlier this week about the importance of using the full 31-man squad during the pool stages to avoid "discord".

Mistakes have been learnt from the past. The players trust Schmidt's game-plan and he trusts whoever he selects to carry it out effectively. We should all do the same.

Belfast Telegraph

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting?

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph