Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Freedom Act: US law limits snooping as UK gears up to make its spies far more powerful

Published 03/06/2015

US has limited the powers of its intelligence agencies for the first time in over 30 years, but there’s little chance of anything similar happening in the UK
US has limited the powers of its intelligence agencies for the first time in over 30 years, but there’s little chance of anything similar happening in the UK

The US has dramatically limited the powers of its spy agencies, just as the UK gears up to hugely increase what its own can do.

The Senate passed the USA Freedom Act last night, placing new restrictions and oversight on the way that the country’s National Security Agency can spy on citizens, in what was hailed as a victory for privacy campaigners and a direct result of the Snowden leaks.

But in the UK, lawmakers are getting ready to pass into law the “Snoopers’ Charter” — which among other things imposes that internet service providers must store information on their users so that intelligence agencies can access them. After the majority Conservative government was elected, the Draft Communications Bill could include even more powers, with David Cameron having threatened to ban or reduce the encryption that is used to keep data secure.

The Freedom Bill constrains exactly those kinds of powers — banning the storage of phone records indiscriminately. Campaigners successfully argued that meant that US citizens were having their personal information held despite never being convicted of a crime, because of the NSA’s “dragnet” approach, which gathered information on everyone.

Instead, those records will be held by the phone companies. That is also what the Snoopers’ Charter aims to do, though that would be a matter of giving more surveillance powers rather than less.

Privacy campaigners EFF said that the Freedom Bill marked “a day that some said could never happen—a day when the NSA saw its surveillance power reduced by Congress”. That could be “a turning point in the fight to rein in the NSA”, the campaign group said.

But campaigners said that the act didn’t go far enough, partly since it left in place the same bulk collection rules that the UK wants to implement.

“The bill leaves many of the government’s most intrusive and overbroad surveillance powers untouched, and it makes only very modest adjustments to disclosure and transparency requirements,” said Jameel Jaffer, the deputy legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union. “Over the next weeks and months, lawmakers must tackle the larger project of bringing the government’s surveillance practices back in line with democratic values.”

Though the Snowden leaks exposed wide-ranging spying powers in the UK as well as the US, the response has been much less intense, especially among politicians on the right. In the US, Republican politicians including Rand Paul have been a key part of the campaign to reduce the spying powers of government agencies.

The UK has previously committed to overhaul the legal framework that permits spying, after a parliamentary committee said that it was “unnecessarily complicated and — crucially — lacks transparency”. But their recommendations were only that the law should be re-written to clarify it, and potentially add transparency, not that it should limit or change the powers given to intelligence agencies.

Source: Independent

Further reading

UK government rewrites surveillance law to get away with hacking and allow cyber attacks, campaigners claim

Net police: Plans to allow cops to vet internet communications

Snoopers' charter set to return to law as Theresa May suggests Conservative majority could lead to huge increase in surveillance powers  

FREAK security flaw: Apple and Google users being spied on for a decade

Sim card maker Gemalto says it was hacked by GCHQ and NSA but claims encryption keys are safe

Edward Snowden: NSA still collecting everybody's information including your d**k pics

'Prosecute spies who abuse powers'

Wikimedia Foundation sues NSA over mass surveillance programme

Mass surveillance of UK citizens on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and Google is legal, says government’s top anti-terror chief Charles Farr

Facebook status updates and Twitter posts intercepted by UK Government  

Vodafone: governments use secret wires to listen to all conversations on mobile network  

Snooping tools GCHQ could use to hack your phone's microphone, camera and keypad: Nosey Smurf, Gumfish and Foggybottom

52% wary of expressing their views online, one in three do not feel free from government surveillance

GCHQ ‘using online viruses and honey traps to discredit targets’  

GCHQ given access to US 'Dishfire' system that reads hundreds of millions of text messages from around the world, according to NSA documents leaked by Edward Snowden

NSA can spy on computers not connected to internet using radio waves

BT 'refuses to deny data handover'

GCHQ 'harvested webcam images'  

GCHQ ‘using online viruses and honey traps to discredit targets’  

Spymasters swoop on Angry Birds

US bid to stop spying on its spying  

Obama vows NSA phone data reform

GCHQ given access to US 'Dishfire' system that reads hundreds of millions of text messages from around the world, according to NSA documents leaked by Edward Snowden

Internet founder hails Snowden  

Snowden gives TV Christmas message

NSA and GCHQ agents acted as elves and gnomes to spy on gamers using World of Warcraft and Second Life

Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales: Edward Snowden is a hero  

NSA spied on pornography use and ‘online promiscuity’ as part of plan to discredit those with radical views, according to leaked documents

GCHQ ran hotel surveillance ring to spy on diplomats and delegations

GCHQ set up fake LinkedIn pages to spy on mobile phone giants using 'Quantum Insert' technique

Google engineers on NSA and GCHQ surveillance: "F*** these guys"

Germany demands explanation from British ambassador Simon McDonald over GCHQ's 'secret listening post in the heart of Berlin'

Britain’s GCHQ has ‘secret listening post in the heart of Berlin to eavesdrop on the seat of German power'

Civil liberties groups claim British spy agency GCHQ broke European laws by hacking millions of citizens’ internet data

Independent News Service

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Read More