Belfast Telegraph

Home Life Books

Nothing new in this clumsy attempt at satire on terrorism

Lionel Shriver's latest novel is set in Barba, a fictional peninsula which juts out (like a beard) from Portugal's southern border. No one would take much notice of it but for the existence of a home-grown terrorist organisation, which has claimed any number of atrocities in the name of Barban independence.

It's also the reason why a group of foreign journalists is stationed in the dusty capital, Cinzeiro, quarrelling as they wait for the next bomb.

The latest addition to this little band is Edgar Kellogg, a rookie American foreign correspondent with a thin file of clippings. Kellogg has abruptly switched careers from corporate law to journalism.

He gets a lucky break when a contact from his school days, now a star reporter, puts in a word for him with the editor of the National Record in New York. The editor has a gap to fill after his Barban correspondent, Barrington Saddler, has gone missing amid rumours that he's been abducted or murdered.

The set-up - hapless hack arrives in backwater about which he knows next to nothing - is familiar. Evelyn Waugh's Scoop (1938) is the prototype but Shriver's novel takes aim at international terrorism as much as journalism. Her terrorists, the Daring Soldiers of Barba, attack targets all over the world while their political wing pours out the usual rhetoric about colonialism and liberation. Like any modern conflict it has religious and ethnic dimensions, with the Catholic terrorists calling for the expulsion of Muslim immigrants from north Africa.

The terrorists' acronym, SOB, offers a flavour of Shriver's tone in this tale of jaded foreign correspondents - she was a correspondent for some years out of Belfast - and ranting ideologues. So does the name chosen for the SOB's political wing: O Creme de Barbear, which translates literally as 'shaving cream'. It quickly starts to feel a trifle heavy-handed, but then this is not a novel that delivers subtlety or unexpected insights. Kellogg is a typically insecure reporter, but his assignment enmeshes him in rivalries with more successful men.

There hasn't been a single SOB atrocity since Saddler's disappearance, but it takes Kellogg an unconscionable amount of time to wonder whether there is a connection; he also fails to grasp the significance of later discoveries at Saddler's home. Shriver revels in writing about her backbiting reporters, but it's hard to imagine a bunch of seasoned hacks proving quite so gullible.

The novel is poorly constructed, relying on stagey devices and a deus ex machina when the plot reaches what might otherwise have been an impasse. Shriver says nothing new about journalism or terrorism, and it isn't a surprise to discover that the novel was actually written before the 9/11 attacks. It's finally been published on the back of Shriver's success with So Much For That and We Need To Talk About Kevin, but it's much less accomplished.

There's nothing wrong in principle about writing a satire on international terrorism, but The New Republic misses its mark. Sadly, it's just another novel about a bunch of pissed old hacks.


From Belfast Telegraph