Belfast Telegraph

Home Life Features

Was life really better in the days of Downton Abbey?

By Simon Kelner

As if the ITV publicity department wasn't doing enough to promote the new series of Downton Abbey, the head of the TUC gives the show a further burst of headlines.

"Are we going to settle... for a Downton Abbey-style society," asked Frances O'Grady, "in which the living standards of the vast majority are sacrificed to protect the high living of the well-to-do?"

It was a rhetorical flourish which was calculated to attract attention – and who can blame Ms O'Grady?

The live BBC coverage of the TUC leader's speech about the iniquities of modern Britain, where the privileged few still hold sway, was interrupted to bring news of a second baby for the Duchess of Cambridge. You could say this was suitably ironic, but Ms O'Grady clearly understands that the British public love an upper-class soap opera.

In any case, I'm not sure she's on the right track with her analogy. The contention that Victorian society was inherently "nastier and poorer" may be correct, but most people who tune in to Downton Abbey are struck by the benevolent, paternalistic attitude of the haves towards the have-nots.

The Granthams are portrayed as a caring, socially aware family, bestowing patronage on the lower orders and mindful of the less fortunate.

And wasn't this the era of the great philanthropists, the Frys and the Rowntrees, who ploughed their vast riches into making the lives of the poorest in society more palatable and who had a vision of a fairer, more equitable UK?

Ms O'Grady is right to focus on the widening inequalities in today's United Kingdom – something that increased, shamefully, under the last Labour administration – but it is as much a social issue as it is a political one.

The lack of social mobility, the retrenchment of rights for the lowest-paid workers, the vast discrepancies between rich and poor, and between the regions – exacerbated by the influx of the global mega-rich to London – is a clear threat to the social stability of the nation.

The TUC of 2014 may be something of a neutered beast and there was an element of Spartism in some of Ms O'Grady's comments.

But someone has got to draw meaningful attention to the grotesque injustices, inequalities and disparities that blight the UK today.

And I don't hear any of our political leaders doing that.

Belfast Telegraph

Daily News Headlines Newsletter

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox.


From Belfast Telegraph