Belfast Telegraph

Trawling for shellfish decimating precious marine life

The by-catch taken in fine mesh prawn trawls, with a few of the shellfish overwhelmingly outnumbered by the fish and marine life that has been indiscriminately swept up
The by-catch taken in fine mesh prawn trawls, with a few of the shellfish overwhelmingly outnumbered by the fish and marine life that has been indiscriminately swept up

By Linda Stewart

This stark image shows the devastating impact of decades of intensive fishing of our seas.

An arsenal of environmental problems has been building beneath the waves, according to marine experts.

All this week the Belfast Telegraph is running a special ‘Save Our Seas’ series, revealing the devastating pressures that are draining our seas and waterways of life.

Cod stocks have crashed, as have sole and whiting. Our fishing industry now depend on catching vast quantities of prawns — and that should be setting off warning signals.

This startling image shows the prawn by-catch at an Irish port taken in a fine mesh prawn trawl.

Marine expert Professor Callum Roberts, who revealed on Monday how much of our rich fishing grounds in the Irish Sea have been reduced to mud and sand, says it reveals how our prawn industry is a fishery of last resort.

“You can spot a few prawns in there, but they are overwhelmingly outnumbered by the collateral losses of juvenile fish, adult fish and seabed life that has been indiscriminately swept up,” he said.

“This is a fishery of last resort. It is what remains when we have overexploited pretty much everything else, and while we continue fishing like this, there is no prospect of any recovery for the rest.”

Environmental campaigners say the prawn fishery is only successful because all the predators have been fished out, leaving only scavengers.

Richard Devlin, of Northern Ireland Marine Task Force, described how the ‘blip’ during the Second World War that halted fishing on the Atlantic brought a surge in fish stocks.

“Just after the Second World War, it was said that you could walk from Ireland to New York on the backs of cod,” he said.

“After less than 100 years of increasingly industrialised exploitation, habitats have already been lost, fish stocks have declined to alarming levels and the pressure on our marine world is increasing by the day.

“By the 1970s fish stocks crashed to alarming levels. We are now over-reliant on prawns because the fish stock we used to fish are gone.

“Fifty years ago we were landing the top predators — cod, haddock, halibut.

“Now we are landing the scavengers with that fishing stock decline.”

He and other green campaigners insist it is crucial that effective protected Marine Conservation Zones be set up as part of the forthcoming Marine Bill and this is vital to protect the health of our fisheries as well as conservation.

Geoff Nuttall, NI director of WWF, says over half of our wildlife lives in our seas, yet only around 4% of it has any legal protection.

“We have 17 different whale, dolphin and porpoise species and 27 species of marine sponge around Rathlin Island not found anywhere else in the world. Strangford Lough, designated as the UK’s first and largest Marine Nature Reserve, is home to an estimated 2,000 marine species,” he says.

“Tragically, however, these marine treasures have suffered major damage over the years, such as the damage done to Strangford Lough’s biogenic horse mussel reefs which support at least 100 other species, attributed to dredging for scallops — ironically, one of the very species supported by the reefs.

“It is sad to think that it has taken the threat of EU fines of £8m for action to be taken to safeguard our own unique and often irreplaceable natural assets.”

Northern Ireland is still waiting to hear what action the EU is going to take over our failure to protect the rare Modiolus horse mussel beds in Strangford Lough.

The EU has announced it has embarked on infraction proceedings, despite belated conservation efforts which have seen two no-take zones set up to protect the beds.

It is precisely this debacle that points to the need for an overarching Marine Management Organisation that oversees all the functions impinging on the seas — adjudicating over competing demands for conservation, shipping, fishing, renewable energy and aggregates extraction.

But last week the environment committee decided not to insist on an amendment to the Marine Bill that would have seen such an MMO replace the 30-odd departments whose activities affect the sea, instead voting to set up a working group and a Memorandum of Understanding between departments.

“Everyone knows the current system isn’t working. We need a one-stop shop for marine matters,” Mr Devlin said.

“Strangford Lough would not have happened had there been a single unitary authority. We wouldn’t have had DARD and DoE pointing and looking at each other and going: ‘To you, to me, to you’. There are too many faultlines with the current model.”

Belfast Telegraph


From Belfast Telegraph