Belfast Telegraph

Clergyman offers to help resolve parishioner standoff after police storm church amid furious protests

Minister George Speers
Minister George Speers
Protesters in Ballynahinch Congregational Church on Sunday evening


The most senior official in an Irish church has said he has never seen anything like the conflict between parishioners and their minister in one divided congregation this week.

Rev Victor Neill's comments came after police officers stormed a service at Ballynahinch Congregational Church after a minister was surrounded by a group of angry worshippers on Sunday.

During the extraordinary standoff, the Rev George Speers used a megaphone in a bid to drown out those jeering him from the pews while preaching.

Years of tensions and disputes have split parishioners into church-goers who support the minister and those who want the minister to leave.

"We wouldn't wish this on anyone, we haven't seen anything like it before," said Rev Neill, the chairman of the Congregational Union of Ireland.

"There are sometimes issues like this – but I have never seen them reach this stage."

Ballynahinch Congregational Church is one of the 27 that makes up the Congregational Union of Ireland.

But the governing body cannot intervene unless it is invited.

Rev Neill said: "We can do no more than offer our help and wait and see.

"We issued our statement to both sides but no-one has come forward."

Geoff Buchanan is the leader of the Boys' Brigade at the church and told the Belfast Telegraph he understands both sides in the bitter row.

But he added that he didn't think the behaviour of those protesting was appropriate in a church setting.

"There were a lot of young children there and it is hard to justify that sort of behaviour and level of noise," he said.

"I am pretty neutral in this, but both sides have dug trenches and are very reluctant to back down.

"There needs to be a cooling off period and mediation so both sides can learn to be in the same building together."

The long-running dispute which reached boiling point at the weekend has had a huge impact on those involved.

Trustee Trevor Carruthers (69) said: "I was 12 stone 6 when this all began and I dropped to 10 stone 6."

Fellow trustee Jimmy McClenaghan (71) said: "This has been going on for more than two years, people can't sleep at night.

"I know one lady who went to the doctors to get tablets and the doctor said, 'I suppose you belong to that church as well over there.'"

Last night, the trustees of the church who claim that they support the church but not the minister held a meeting to work out what they plan to do in the current situation, which they described as "terrible".


On Sunday, around 40 church members left their seats in Ballynahinch Congregational Church and began to shout at the minister. They roared "Out, Out, Out", clapping, whistling and cheering, surrounding the pulpit. One man was spoken to by police for unplugging the organ.

Belfast Telegraph


From Belfast Telegraph