Belfast Telegraph

Foster and Sinn Fein at impasse over ill thought out green energy plan

A bitter impasse over Arlene Foster's refusal to stand down as Stormont First Minister has prevented agreement on proposals for an independent investigation into her role in a botched green energy scheme.

While Democratic Unionist leader Mrs Foster has voiced support for a judge-led probe outlined by her Sinn Fein partners in government, she again emphatically rejected the republican party's prerequisite that she temporarily step aside to facilitate it.

Mrs Foster, who continues to face down a barrage of calls to leave the stage, presided over the development of the error-ridden scheme during her time as economy minister.

Flaws in the Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI) have left the DUP/Sinn Fein coalition administration facing a £490 million bill.

While her statement on Friday evening adopted a somewhat more conciliatory tone in comparison to recent vexed exchanges with Sinn Fein over the scandal, the First Minister made clear she will not give ground on what is one of their key demands.

Mrs Foster accused political opponents of wanting to be her "judge, jury and executioner".

In response, Sinn Fein reiterated their stance that consensus on a probe would not be reached unless she stood aside.

"It is clear there are many in the political class who do not believe in due process or natural justice," said the DUP leader.

"They just want me to go regardless of the fact that there is not a scintilla of evidence of wrongdoing against me. I don't roll over to my political opponents.

"I believe in getting to the truth. I believe in due process for everyone and that everyone is equal before the law and equally subject to the law. That has always been the cornerstone of who I am and will be so despite the hysteria."

Sinn Fein Assembly member Caral Ni Chuilin said the DUP had not officially notified the party of its stance on the proposals.

She added: "Sinn Fein has also made it clear that Arlene Foster needs to stand aside pending a preliminary report from the independent investigation which must have the powers to compel witnesses and evidence."

Earlier, the DUP leader posted a meme on Facebook of a guinea pig wearing a pair of pink love heart-shaped glasses below the phrase: "Can't see all the haters when I've got my love glasses on."

She has claimed many of the calls for her to quit are motivated by misogyny.

The state-funded RHI was supposed to offer a proportion of the cost businesses had to pay to run eco-friendly boilers, but the subsidy tariffs were set too high, and without a cap, it ended up paying out significantly more than the price of fuel.

This enabled applicants to "burn to earn" - getting free heat and making a profit as they did it.

Claims of widespread abuse include a farmer allegedly set to pocket around £1 million in the next two decades for heating an empty shed.

On Friday morning, Sinn Fein Health Minister, Michelle O'Neill, said the key element of their proposals is the need to be able to compel witnesses and subpoena documents.

"If Arlene Foster wants to do the right thing, the right thing to do is to stand aside," she said.

The scandal has erupted at a time when Sinn Fein Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness has been experiencing health problems.

Mrs O'Neill said her party colleague remained at the core of the party's response to the RHI affair.

The lack of consensus over the form of an investigation comes amid similar disagreement on DUP proposals to reduce the overspend. The DUP has claimed its proposals could wipe out the bill, but Sinn Fein have rubbished them.

Senior members of Sinn Fein have warned they will exercise their power to collapse the Executive if Mrs Foster does not temporarily stand down to facilitate an RHI probe.

If the republican party follows through with that threat, Northern Ireland will be facing a snap Assembly election, less than a year after the last one.

Earlier, Stormont's independent justice minister accused Northern Ireland's political leaders of letting her down over their handling of the furore.

Claire Sugden said she favoured an independent probe, but did not support calls for Mrs Foster to step down.

Ms Sugden also ruled out quitting her pivotal job - a move that would likely force the collapse of the DUP/Sinn Fein-led coalition.

The power-sharing executive cannot function without a justice minister and Ms Sugden was the only Assembly member both DUP leader Mrs Foster and Mr McGuinness could agree on in the wake of last year's election.

"Martin and Arlene have both let me down," she said.

The East Londonderry MLA said: "Arlene and Martin might have reneged on their responsibilities to actually do a job for the people of Northern Ireland, but I am not going to do that because I do have integrity and I will keep doing it until I can't."

The justice minister had not commented publicly on the RHI scandal for more than two weeks - prompting criticism from political rivals.

Breaking her recent silence, Ms Sugden said her job had become increasingly difficult.

But she said she would not resign because she still felt she could help change people's lives for the better in her role. She also stressed that her quitting would send the Executive down a "path of no return".

In an interview with BBC Radio Ulster, the minister said: "I think with this particular issue there is a lot of political posturing going on.

"Regrettably, the two main parties are reverting to party politics and they are feathering their own nests in that respect - they are keeping their own constituents right."

Ms Sugden said she did not believe calls for Mrs Foster to stand aside were fair.

"Anyone forcing her to step aside is actually punishing her for something that hasn't been substantiated," she said.

It was originally envisaged that the Treasury would foot the bill for the RHI, but the costs spiralled well beyond London's financial commitment.

The total RHI spend in Northern Ireland is estimated at £1,150 million over the next 20 years.

The Treasury is set to cover £660 million of that, with Stormont landed with the remaining £490 million.

In another development set to further challenge the fraying relations between Stormont's two main parties, Sinn Fein announced it was lodging a motion of no confidence in the Assembly's DUP speaker.

Robin Newton has been under political pressure over his handling of a recalled Assembly session to debate RHI before Christmas.

He has also been forced to defend himself against conflict of interest accusations in regard to his handling of Assembly exchanges on a controversial charity in his east Belfast constituency.

Sinn Fein's Declan Kearney said: "He is now part of the problem and an integral part of the unfolding crisis and he should resign immediately."


From Belfast Telegraph