Belfast Telegraph

It’s not Rose Neill and it’s not Moira Stuart... photo of mystery woman in green keeps them guessing

The mystery reporter in a green trouser suit on Belfast’s Crumlin Road
The mystery reporter in a green trouser suit on Belfast’s Crumlin Road
Moira Stuart
Jan Leeming
Ivan Little

By Ivan Little

It's the 'who's that girl?' mystery that's got everybody talking.

But the puzzle over the identity of the woman in green on the cover of a new book about the Troubles still hasn't been resolved despite dozens of people weighing in with suggestions about who she is.

The response to appeals in the Belfast Telegraph earlier this week for readers to come up with a name for the female journalist has been remarkable, coming from people as far away as Canada and France.

The reporter in the photograph is seen conducting interviews on the Crumlin Road in Belfast after a bomb blast in 1972.

The picture was chosen for the book Reporting the Troubles by the publishers from a file of images from a major photographic agency, but there were no details about the journalist standing amid the wreckage.

As co-compiler of Reporting the Troubles, my colleague Deric Henderson and I consulted widely about the identity of the woman but to no avail. And it's been a matter of intense debate among readers since the book was released in September.

And ever since the story about the woman appeared in Tuesday's Belfast Telegraph I have been inundated with emails.

Among the most 'popular' suggestions have been Maggie Taggart and Maxine Mawhinney from the BBC and Rose Neill of UTV but they hadn't begun their journalistic careers in 1972.

Others including the editor of the Belfast Telegraph, Gail Walker hadn't even started school 46 years ago.

Another two names that have been put forward have been that of a more seasoned journalist Diane Harron who worked for the BBC locally and nationally and Eileen Magnier of RTE.

A new exhibition revealing the desolation and destruction experienced during the Troubles will be launched in Belfast next week.
A new exhibition revealing the desolation and destruction experienced during the Troubles will be launched in Belfast next week.
Photographer Sean Hillen. Credit Greg Dunn.
At The Field. I like this image of the twin boys in their sashes. Twins always have a funny effect in any photo because it reminds the brain of a trick or illusion of some kind.
Mourners line a wall at the funeral in Derry of hunger-striker Patsy O'Hara
I was fascinated by this burnt-out shell of a bus effectively jamming an access road to the Divis Flats. My father was a bus driver and I was curious to see what the bus was made of its interesting that the steel frame is left while the body, which is aluminium and plastic, has burned away.
A group of youths at the head of the parade dance extravagantly for my camera. Note the Olympic Boot Factory in the background (named after the Olympic ocean liner, sister-ship to the Titanic), along with the ubiquitous policeman.
This lady is walking past what had been the Clonard Picture House on the Falls Road (opened in 1913), with the remains of the foyer swept back in off the pavement. Note the black flag, which was part of the campaign over the Republican prisoners, and the furniture for sale, which may have been a result of people losing their homes.
This Union Jack and enticing advertisement were at the front of a Baptist church at the northern edge of Newry town centre. I took an even nicer frame before this photo, with one Orangeman pointing his umbrella at the sign, but the negative was sadly too badly scratched to be repaired.
The next few photos are of the Belfast Twelfth parade, taken in my first year of art school in 1979. This man was a familiar sight in Belfast at that time. I found him here in a prominent position on Royal Avenue, with the City Hall in the far background.
I love this photo of two young Orangemen relaxed enough to lie back and contemplate the sky after the parade.
The people standing around this boarded-up bar in West Belfast told me that the night before a British Army armoured car had driven through the corner doorway, demolishing it.
Later the same day I passed the bar again and found this man rebuilding it.
My attention was particularly taken by the girls Country and Western style outfit. This family was waiting to watch the parade pass down Sandy Street in Newry.
An older Orangeman rests against the chip van in 'the field' outside Newry, mid 1980's
Patsy OHaras funeral had a uniquely double or joint colour party of IRA as well as INLA members. A journalist friend noticed that there were women among them.
Young supporters would accompany the parade, singing and dancing along to the band music. Outside the old Co-Operative building in Royal Avenue I spotted these two girls. The one on the right has just bought a record from Easons, my bet is Rod Stewart.
I clambered on to a scaffolding platform erected for the press and found a space at the rail, which gave a pretty good view as the funeral proceeded. I had brought along what was known as a portrait lens; a fixed, slightly longfocus lens with a wide aperture, good in low light. I made use of it here and was struck that I could see the eyes of this individual so clearly.
Patsy O'Hara Funeral.
1992 Easter Parade. The Easter Parade has arrived at the entrance to the graveyard and the cohort of police vehicles pulls in ahead of it.
Patsy O'Hara Funeral The harrowed and grief-stricken expression of the lady still seems to me both tragic and sobering.
This youth asserted that he had been injured by a plastic bullet.
Around 1983 or 84 I photographed this Annual Procession of the Ancient Order of Hibernians. It is, as far as I can see, a sort of social club for ordinary Catholics and at its roots has a romantic and Catholic Nationalist tendency. When I arrived they were assembling in the lee of the church for this group photo, which made my project easier.
Two old men on a bench and a Marine Commando playing with his safety-catch of his rifle, at Sugar Island in the centre of Newry Co. Down, on a Twelfth of July around 1985. Newry was over 90% Catholic and the occasion would be tense with very few people were on the streets but police and soldiers. I spotted this scene and mentally framed the picture. It was illegal by definition to photograph 'the Security Forces' so I asked the soldier 'can I take a picture' and I think he nodded, so I fired one frame (shooting 35mm black-and-white film very sparingly), then I waited, shot another one, waited again and then the man in the middle looked up and that's my picture. Someone told me he's a Marine Commando and he's playing with the safety-catch of the rifle. From The SeaÃÅn Hillen Collection of photographs recently acquired by the National Library of Ireland Photographic Archive
Hunger Strike March While hanging around a busy junction in a crowd of people waiting for the march, I struck up a conversation with this lady, who was quite animated and talkative
view of the Mass Rock altar and the crowd assembling for the Mass Rock event in the Mourne Mountains, mid-1980s.

Two of the BBC's most famous national newsreaders have also had their names thrown into the mix.

But Jan Leeming and Moira Stuart aren't believed to have been front-line journalists.

Several people have suggested that the journalist may have been a foreign correspondent who was on a flying visit to Belfast, which would explain why so few people here have been able to recognise her.

Several emailers have given names which Henderson and I are trying to follow up on the internet.

Other emailers have said they think the journalist might be the late Irish writer Mary Holland.

On Twitter former Sinn Fein publicity director Danny Morrison has asked if the woman could be Mairin de Burca, a campaigning journalist and ex-general secretary of his party.

Unionist MLA and former UTV presenter Mike Nesbitt has questioned if the woman in the photo might actually be a police officer rather than a journalist.

And another reader said she thought the lady in green may have been holding a piece of debris rather than a microphone.

One emailer who couldn't give any clues about the woman was however able to supply more details about the bombing.

He said the device exploded in a stolen car parked outside the Crumlin cinema near where he worked on Saturday, May 27, 1972.

No one was killed but seven people were injured.

One of them was William Christie, later Sir William, who was the Lord Mayor designate of Belfast and who owned a wallpaper shop on the Crumlin Road.

Not everyone who has responded to the pleas for information has clearly taken the request seriously.

One man suggested that the woman in green was WD Flackes, the BBC's veteran (male) political correspondent.

Anyone with any more thoughts about the identity of the woman in green should email me at

Belfast Telegraph


From Belfast Telegraph