Belfast Telegraph

Legal boost for Ballymurphy families over denial of funding for inquests

By Alan Erwin

The families of 10 people shot dead by soldiers in west Belfast 45 years ago have won High Court permission to challenge the withholding of funding for inquests into the deaths.

Lawyers for the Ballymurphy families were granted leave to seek a judicial review against the Stormont Executive and the UK Government.

They claim the continued refusal to release resources is thwarting a five-year plan devised by Northern Ireland’s most senior judge to deal with a backlog of tribunals into Troubles-related killings.

Barrister Fiona Doherty QC said: “These legacy inquests have been sucked into the pernicious politics of this jurisdiction.

“It’s time for the court to exercise its constitutional role and uphold the rule of law.”

Legal proceedings were issued on behalf of a daughter of one of the civilians shot dead in Ballymurphy over a three-day period during the introduction of internment in August 1971.

A separate action is being taken on behalf of the families of eight IRA men ambushed and killed by the SAS at Loughgall, Co Armagh, in May 1987.

Both challenges are aimed at securing an order for the release of money required to hear all outstanding legacy inquests.

Lord Chief Justice Sir Declan Morgan has called for urgent action to fund his blueprint for having all cases dealt with within five years.

With the cost of the plan estimated at around £10m, the Government has said resources will not be released until a political agreement is reached.

In court yesterday counsel for the Department of Justice and the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland said he was not opposing leave to seek a judicial review in the Ballymurphy proceedings.

Tony McGleenan QC accepted that an arguable case worthy of further consideration had been raised.

He also confirmed no instructions had been provided by the third respondent in the case — the Office of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister.

Ms Doherty emphasised how the Lord Chief Justice’s plan represents “extraordinary progress” from his previous warning that legacy inquests could be continuing in 2040. She contended that it was now time for the Government to intervene.

Following submissions, Mr Justice Maguire ruled that he was granting leave to apply for a judicial review in the Ballymurphy case.

He adjourned the Loughgall challenge for lawyers to refine the points being made in the papers.

With issues over managing a wider range of inquest-related court actions, the judge has yet to decide which will be the lead case to deal with the issues raised.

He explained: “I’m looking for a vehicle that can be heard swiftly and will not be caught up in a long period of gestation.”

Earlier, lawyers acting for the Loughgall families accused DUP First Minister Arlene Foster of being responsible for the funding logjam.

Mr McGleenan responded that any allegations of discrimination being made against the Department of Justice and Secretary of State were unsustainable.

He also stressed that the challenge was against a decision taken after the Assembly elections and formation of a new Stormont Executive.

Adjourning the Loughgall case, Mr Justice Maguire directed a redrafting of points being made in the legal papers.

Belfast Telegraph


From Belfast Telegraph