No evidence of institutional abuse at Dunmurry Manor care home – regulator
The watchdog disagreed with parts of a scathing report by an elderly person’s advocate which examined the care of those with dementia.
There was no evidence of institutional abuse at Dunmurry Manor care home in Belfast, a watchdog said.
The regulator disagreed with parts of a scathing report by an elderly person’s advocate which examined the care of those with dementia.
The conclusion that some were allegedly exposed to sexualised behaviour by fellow residents was presented in an unjustified fashion, the Regulation and Quality Improvement (RQIA) authority said.
We do not agree that this meets the definition of institutional abuse RQIA
It added: “RQIA does not agree with some of the Commissioner’s conclusions.
“Most seriously, we found no evidence of institutional abuse and do not believe that the commissioner’s findings support this statement.”
The RQIA statement said it found instances where the quality of care was not to the expected standard and worked with the management of the home to support improvement.
Follow-up inspections found that care did get better for a period.
“We do not agree that this meets the definition of institutional abuse,” RQIA said.
Commissioner for Older People for Northern Ireland (COPNI) Eddie Lynch has said the failure to put in place a robust process to protect female residents had violated their right to enjoy their home and private life.
Sexualised behaviour is not uncommon in those with dementia and is not regarded as criminal activity, the RQIA watchdog said.
It added: “In respect of the findings of resident-on-resident sexual assault, RQIA is very concerned at how the commissioner has chosen to present this finding.
This is uncomfortable reading but the failings of our systems must be known in order to have accountability. The @copni reports into Dunmurry Manor Care Home are now online— AEA Northern Ireland (@AEA_NIreland) June 13, 2018
Full report - https://t.co/8LHRp0SJiz
Summary report - https://t.co/JDwSXkt9Th#HomeTruths #ElderAbuse pic.twitter.com/bQ5L2MC8YX
“Disinhibited sexualised behaviour is not uncommon in people with dementia.
“For that reason, it is not regarded as criminal activity and is dealt with sensitively by health and social care trust safeguarding teams who work closely with care providers to mitigate risks to all residents and to develop care plans that recognise such behaviours as a potential expression of distress.
“RQIA does not believe there is any justification for the Commissioner’s presentation of this finding and is concerned about the impact on residents and their families.”
The regulator said it did not receive a significant number of contacts from families or carers of residents in this home.
“We have therefore reflected on our public profile and will be focusing on improving this in the coming year.”
Mr Lynch identified “significant failures” in the safeguarding and care of residents.
He said he found evidence of patients turning on other patients and subjecting them to alleged physical and sexual assaults amid an unsafe environment where such risks were not properly managed.
Mr Lynch said he was shocked at the RQIA’s tone.
He said his safeguarding and human rights expert was in no doubt that the evidence provided supported the finding of concerns of institutional abuse at Dunmurry Manor.
“Health and Social Care Trust documentation submitted in evidence showed Trust officials’ concerns about this very issue.”
He said his report reflected all evidence submitted including information submitted by the RQIA and the Health and Social Care Trusts, all of which was analysed by his expert panel.
He said the person on the receiving end of sexualised behaviour was an adult in need of protection.
“Nowhere in my investigation report has this behaviour been referred to as criminal.
“People live with dementia all over Northern Ireland and a good care home will have the expertise and staff available to manage these behaviours when they do occur.”