Belfast Telegraph

Retired general: ‘Most if not all’ killed by army at Ballymurphy were not IRA

Sir Geoffrey Howlett, commander of the Second Battalion, Parachute Regiment, between 1971 and 1973, gave evidence to the Ballymurphy inquest.

Mourners filing past the coffin of Father Hugh Mullan, one of the victims of the Ballymurphy shootings, at Corpus Christi church on the Ballymurphy estate in Belfast.
Mourners filing past the coffin of Father Hugh Mullan, one of the victims of the Ballymurphy shootings, at Corpus Christi church on the Ballymurphy estate in Belfast.
A coroner is examining a series of shootings by members of the Parachute Regiment (Cate McCurry/PA).

Most if not all those killed following gunfire by soldiers during a pitched battle in west Belfast were not in the IRA, a retired army general said.

Ten people died over three “rebellious” days at the start of internment of suspected paramilitaries without trial early in the Troubles.

A coroner is examining a series of shootings by members of the Parachute Regiment.

Sir Geoffrey Howlett, 89, expressed “enormous sympathy” with families whose relatives perished in Ballymurphy in August 1971.

The 10 victims of the Ballymurphy Massacre (Ballymurphy Massacre Committee/PA)
The 10 victims of the Ballymurphy Massacre (Ballymurphy Massacre Committee/PA)

One of the highest-ranking former British officers to appear before a Northern Irish inquest into conflict deaths said in Belfast: “I realise now that most, if not all, were not IRA.”

He accepted anyone who was not rioting could not be associated with armed republicans, despite the acknowledged level of support for the IRA in the area.

Tensions linked to internment saw disorder escalate into what the soldier described as a full-blown battle, and many hundreds of rounds were fired at his men.

Riots: Belfast. August 1970. Soldiers shelter behind their riot shields during rioting at Ballymurphy. (04/08/70)
Riots: Belfast. August 1970. Soldiers shelter behind their riot shields during rioting at Ballymurphy. (04/08/70)

The then-lieutenant colonel was commander of the Second Battalion, the Parachute Regiment, between 1971 and 1973.

A contemporaneous regimental note before the inquest said soldiers viewed the incident as one of inflicting “severe casualties” on the IRA.

Sir Geoffrey accepted the army’s record of the time may have been mistaken.

Riots : Belfast. January 1971. Soldiers frisking passengers and driver of a car on the Springfield Road, near Ballymurphy. (14/01/1971)
Riots : Belfast. January 1971. Soldiers frisking passengers and driver of a car on the Springfield Road, near Ballymurphy. (14/01/1971)
Riots : Belfast. August 1970. Troops shelter behind their riot shields during rioting at Ballymurphy. (04/08/70)
Riots : Belfast. August 1970. The common sight in the Roman Catholic estate at Ballymurphy, Belfast, as young rioters attack the army with missiles during the troubles. (04/08/70)
Riots : Belfast. September 1970. Ballymurphy Disturbance: troops stand by at the junction of Springfield and Whiterock Roads, after a crowd had thrown stones at them and two police cars. (20/09/1970)
Riots : Belfast. January 1971. Catholic housing estate, Ballymurphy. (15/01/1971)
Mourners file past the coffin of Father Hugh Mullan, one of the 10 people killed (PA Archive)
Father Hugh Mullan. Shot at Moyard Park. 9/8/1971 THE FUNERAL HEARSE CARRYING THE BODY OF FATHER HUGH MULLAN TRAVELS ALONG THE ROAD IN BALLYMURPHY ESTATE. 12/8/1971
Joseph Murphy was one of 10 people shot dead by British soldiers in West Belfast in 1971
Pacemaker Press 17/6/10 John McKerr who is one of the 11 people died in the Ballymurphy Massacre in 1971 in West Belfast
Pacemaker Press 17/6/10 Fr Hugh Mullan who is one of the 11 people died in the Ballymurphy Massacre in 1971 in West Belfast
Pacemaker Press 17/6/10 Joseph Corr who is one of the 11 people died in the Ballymurphy Massacre in 1971 in West Belfast
Pacemaker Press 17/6/10 Danny Teggart who is one of the 11 people died in the Ballymurphy Massacre in 1971 in West Belfast
Pacemaker Press 17/6/10 Paddy McCarthy who is one of the 11 people died in the Ballymurphy Massacre in 1971 in West Belfast
Pacemaker Press 17/6/10 John Laverty who is one of the 11 people died in the Ballymurphy Massacre in 1971 in West Belfast
©Press Eye Ltd Northern Ireland - 25th January 2012 Mandatory Credit - Photo-Jonathan Porter/Presseye. Ballymurphy massacre relatives call for a meeting with the Prime Minister, David Cameron. 10 people were shot dead by soldiers in west Belfast in August 1971. The victims, which included a priest and a mother-of-eight, were killed over the course of three days in August 1971 by members of the Parachute Regiment during Operation Demetrius, when people suspected of paramilitary activity were interned. Relatives Rita Bonner, John Teggart and Briege Voyle pictured at the top of the Whiterock Road in west Belfast beside a mural depicting the shootings.

I want just to say to you how sincerely I have enormous sympathy with you all General Sir Geoffrey Howlett

Sir Geoffrey told relatives of the dead: “I want just to say to you how sincerely I have enormous sympathy with you all.”

He added: “I know something about bereavement because my father was killed in Italy in the war when I was 13, and I wanted to know everything about how it happened as well.”

Riots : Belfast. January 1971. Catholic housing estate, Ballymurphy. (15/01/1971)
Riots : Belfast. January 1971. Catholic housing estate, Ballymurphy. (15/01/1971)

He spoke from the witness box at a Belfast courtroom. Three rows of families of the dead sat opposite him in silence.

After the hearing concluded, John Teggart, the son of one of the victims, Daniel Teggart, said it was almost an apology.

Mr Teggart, 44, and Noel Phillips, 19, were shot close to the Henry Taggart Army base near Springfield Park.

Fr Hugh Mullan
Fr Hugh Mullan

Sir Geoffrey said he would not be totally convinced that they were not associated with the IRA, but they were not firing at them.

Campaigner John Teggart added: “For the first time in almost 48 years, Geoffrey has said my father was not an IRA gunman.

“That is a big deal to the families, that is a big lift to the families today.

“We have waited just to hear that one word.”

The Ballymurphy families maintain their loved ones were entirely innocent.

Sir Geoffrey occupied high-ranking military positions, including commander-in-chief of the Allied Forces in northern Europe.

He was at an army headquarters in west Belfast during part of the events in question then went to a base known as Henry Taggart Hall to resupply his men with ammunition.

Up to 40 rounds were fired at his two Land Rovers as they entered the hall.

It was reported to him by B Company, a sub-group of about 100 men, that the violence was started by a large group who attacked soldiers.

He attested that many hundreds of rounds were fired at members of the company.

“The situation was never the same again, life was difficult,” he said.

“Following internment there had become an enemy out there who were definitely armed and firing at us.”

Six people died from shootings on August 9, 1971.

They included Father Hugh Mullan.

Sir Geoffrey said: “It was quite obvious that Fr Mullan was not part of the IRA, and he was almost certainly, I believe, giving the last rites for someone who appeared to be dying.

“Which of the other people who were shot and killed, whether they were IRA at the time, I don’t think we quite knew.”

He paid tribute to the role of clergymen during the conflict.

Sir Geoffrey recalled serious escalation of the violence in west Belfast in 1971 after troops were charged with implementing internment of suspects without trial.

“None of us realised that the day of internment (August 9) and the next day or two would turn out to be such a rebellious period with as much rioting, shooting, petrol and nail bombing as it was.

“I don’t think any of us were quite prepared for the big change.”

The streets were barricaded amid “looting, shooting and bombing”, Sir Geoffrey said.

The witness added: “The situation went from rioting to a full-blown battle.

“It was very busy – certainly the busiest day of my life.”

Rules of engagement known as the yellow card had been introduced to govern the Army’s use of fire.

The general said: “From the ninth for a day or two then, it was not quite fit for purpose.”

After Ballymurphy, no soldier was disciplined and there was no debrief, the witness said.

“We were too busy trying to get Belfast back to normal,” he said.

The battalion left Northern Ireland on August 25 and took a month’s leave.

PA

Popular

From Belfast Telegraph