Belfast Telegraph

Stormont crisis: No appetite for another Northern Ireland assembly election, James Brokenshire says

Northern Ireland Secretary of State James Brokenshire has said there is "no appetite for another election" after the deadline to form a new devolved power-sharing executive at Stormont passed.

With a deadline for forming a new ruling executive following this month's snap election having elapsed on Monday without agreement, the UK government now either has to call yet another poll or potentially reintroduce direct rule from Westminster.

Mr Brokenshire indicated he will delay taking action to allow the region's political leaders some more time to resolve their differences.

Without an executive or agreed budget for the upcoming financial year, control of Stormont's finances will be handed to a senior civil servant on Wednesday, albeit subject to tight spending constraints.

Mr Brokenshire said that was "not sustainable", making clear the final window for negotiations would not be allowed to drift.

"I think there are a short few weeks in order to resolve matters," he said.

"The reason I say that is because of the stark issue in relation to public services here in Northern Ireland and the lack of a budget having been set, and therefore it is the impact on public services on having an extended period that is very much at the forefront of my mind in terms of the responsibilities that we have as the UK Government to provide that assurance to the public here."

The Democratic Unionist/Sinn Fein administration collapsed in January amid a bitter row over a botched green energy scheme. The subsequent snap election campaign laid bare a range of other contentious issues dividing the parties.

The Secretary of State rejected criticism of the Government's handling of the talks to form a new executive and defended the fact Prime Minister Theresa May did not participate in the process. He said the Government had played a "positive and active" role and Mrs May had been kept updated throughout.

He declined to be drawn on calls for an independent mediator to be appointed to inject fresh impetus to negotiations that some politicians have described as a "shambles" to date.

Read more

Northern Ireland Secretary of State - full statement

Under current legislation, the Government is required to call another snap election if a deadline for forming an executive passes.

However, there is some room for manoeuvre, as there is no obligation to set a poll date immediately, rather within a "reasonable period".

Making a public statement at Stormont House, Belfast, after the 4pm deadline passed on Monday, Mr Brokenshire said there was "no appetite" for an immediate election.

The Government could also theoretically go for the nuclear option of reintroducing direct rule, but that move - which would require emergency legislation - looks unlikely at this stage at least.

Mr Brokenshire said there was "an overwhelming desire" among politicians and the public for "strong and stable devolved government".

"We now have a short window of opportunity to resolve outstanding issues and for an executive to be formed," he said.

"Everyone owes it to the people of Northern Ireland to grasp that and provide the political leadership and stability that they want."

Mr Brokenshire said he would make a full statement in the House of Commons on Tuesday setting out a way forward for the region.

Key points

Here are 5 key points made by James Brokenshire after the power-sharing deadline expired without a deal:

  • The Secretary of State is “extremely disappointing that an Executive has not been formed in Northern Ireland today”.
  • Despite progress, there remain significant gaps between the parties, “particularly over issues surrounding culture and identity”, such as the Irish language.
  • From Wednesday, financial resources to allow Northern Ireland’s Departments to deliver key public services will fall under the control of the Northern Ireland Civil Service.
  • There is no appetite for an alternative “to strong and stable devolved government”. There’s no appetite for another snap election either. There is, he says, “a short window of opportunity for parties to form an Executive”.
  • Mr Brokenshire will be making a statement in Parliament on next steps on Tuesday.


Irish Minister for Foreign Affairs Charlie Flanagan said the context of Brexit made it all the more imperative that a new executive was formed as soon as possible.

"The absence of agreement on the establishment of an executive is, for many reasons, deeply regrettable," he said.

"However, it is particularly concerning that a vacuum in devolved government in Northern Ireland should now be occurring just as the island of Ireland faces up to the many serious challenges represented by the UK exit from the EU.

"In these circumstances, all concerned must redouble efforts to achieve the re-establishment of power-sharing government in Northern Ireland, which is so plainly in the interests of all its citizens.

"The Irish Government will continue to advocate very strongly for Northern Ireland's interests to be protected.

"However, there is no substitute for an executive speaking with one voice on these critical issues."

Blame game

Sinn Fein and the Democratic Unionists have blamed each other for the breakdown of the powersharing talks on Sunday night.

DUP leader Arlene Foster claimed Sinn Fein's "inflexible" approach to negotiations was to blame.

She said she did not believe another election would solve anything.

"We wonder whether Sinn Fein were serious about reaching agreement at this time," said the former first minister.

"We are just disappointed that Sinn Fein did not come to the talks in the same spirit as we came to the talks."

She added: "The government of Northern Ireland is not a game, it is actually very serious and the fact we do not have an executive being formed today is very regrettable."

Amid the trading of recriminations, Mrs O'Neill offered a very different view on culpability.

She claimed the DUP had failed to live up to previous agreements and were standing in the way of progressive policies.

"We are standing firm - previous agreements need to be implemented," she said.

"We came at the negotiations with the right attitude, wanting to make the institutions work, wanting to deliver for all citizens.

"Unfortunately, the DUP maintained their position in relation to blocking equality, delivery of equality for citizens, that was the problem."

Read more

Naomi Long: Not once have all parties been around the table together - no-one was chairing the talks

RHI, Irish language

Talks collapsed after Sinn Fein announced it would not be nominating a deputy first minister in the Assembly before the deadline. Without both first and deputy first ministers, it is impossible to form an executive.

Sinn Fein has said it will not share power with Mrs Foster as first minister until a public inquiry into the renewable heat incentive (RHI) is concluded.

Republicans have also been seeking movement on issues such as legislation to protect the Irish language, a hugely symbolic measure but deeply problematic for some unionists.

New mechanisms for dealing with the legacy of the Troubles also remain a source of vexed dispute.

Military Covenant

During the ill-fated negotiations, it is understood the DUP sought progress on implementing the Military Covenant in Northern Ireland, a framework that defines the state's obligations to serving and former members of the Armed Forces, as part of potential new legislation that would also offer more protections for both Irish and Ulster Scots speakers.

A voting surge by Sinn Fein in the snap Assembly election earlier this month saw the party come within one seat of becoming the biggest party at Stormont behind the DUP.

Mr Brokenshire claimed the talks had made progress on some issues - namely around the proposed budget and programme for government; moves to improve governmental transparency and accountability; and steps to implement stalled legacy mechanisms.

He said there was also moves on how Northern Ireland's interests could be best represented in Brexit negotiations.

However, he said "significant gaps" between the parties on "culture and identity" issues mean an overall deal had proved elusive.

How are budgets affected?

Stormont's powersharing arrangements collapsed on Monday after the five major parties failed to reach agreement. Any budget cuts due to the instability could threaten scores of jobs.

Are public services in Northern Ireland going to run out of money?

Ministers have not met as an Executive since mid-winter and major decisions about funding projects like compensation for child resident victims of institutional abuse have been left in abeyance.

No budget or programme for government has been set to govern public spending during the financial year which begins next month.

Organisations like the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) are anticipating a near £20 million cut.

The senior civil servant in Northern Ireland's finance department will take over responsibility for allocating money on Wednesday as part of a "failsafe mechanism".

David Sterling will have responsibility for a sum equivalent to 75% of this year's budget until July. If the political impasse goes on and ministers are not appointed before the end of July, he will have access to a total equivalent to 95% of this year's spending packet.

Stormont's main annual budget for day-to-day spending in 2016-17 was worth just under £10 billion.

Most of that comes in the form of a block grant from Westminster, linked to the amount available for spending in the whole of the UK.

The money which Mr Sterling allocates will be intended to provide a degree of certainty to departments about their spending plans.

It will be concentrated on existing services and no major new initiative is expected.

Who is the man who will have his hands on the purse strings?

Mr Sterling is a hugely experienced civil servant with a background in finance stretching back to the turn of the century.

The married father-of-two, 59, has been responsible for co-ordinating public expenditure planning across the Northern Ireland departments.

He has had oversight of a range of prestige projects including the development of the Titanic Belfast visitor centre, the hosting of the 2012 Irish Open Golf Championship and the 2014 Grande Partenza of the Giro d'Italia cycling race.

In 2013 he chaired the ministerial Executive's G8 summit steering group for hosting the world's most powerful leaders.

So, he will ensure everything will just go on as normal?

Groups delivering services on the ground remain deeply uncertain.

Remember, inflation is eating away at the value of this year's budget settlement and the total needed to increase just to stand still in real terms. The population is ageing and the health service coming under increasing pressure.

A recent survey of voluntary groups which receive funding from Stormont suggested nine out of ten had received or believed they were at risk of cuts.

In the health sector, many GPs have signed undated resignation letters from the NHS over what they believe are funding shortfalls and are considering charging patients for care.

A British Medical Association (BMA) doctor has said she cannot recruit sufficient staff to help alleviate a relentless increase in workload.

In education, teachers have taken strike action over pay, job security and workload.

Sir Malcolm McKibbin, head of the civil service in Northern Ireland, wrote to all his staff.

He said: "Our aim is to ensure 'business as usual' as far as possible though, as I said in my last letter, there will be some things we will not be able to do.

"For example, we will not be able to launch any new programmes, projects or policies which would require ministerial or executive endorsement.

"Departmental accounting officers will also have to be prudent and aim to avoid committing to new patterns of expenditure which would go beyond what they might reasonably expect to be allocated in a budget for 2017/18 once this is agreed."

Belfast Telegraph Digital


From Belfast Telegraph