Belfast Telegraph

Stormont debate and vote on legalising gay marriage in Northern Ireland

Follow all the live debate

Get Adobe Flash player

Follow all the live debate ahead of the Northern Ireland Assembly's motion to vote on legalising same-sex marriage.

Get involved - leave your comments below and let us know what you think by taking our poll

- - - - -

A legal challenge is likely if Northern Ireland is left as the only part of the UK without marriage rights for same-sex couples, Amnesty International has warned.

A controversial proposal to extend legislation to Northern Ireland is set to be defeated in a Stormont vote today.

The Democratic Unionists have tabled a contentious voting mechanism ahead of the debate on a Sinn Fein motion to change marriage laws in the region, meaning it could only pass if a majority of both unionists and nationalists support it.

With the DUP holding the most seats on the unionist side of the house, the party's decision to table a petition of concern means the move to replicate laws already introduced elsewhere in the UK is doomed to fall.

Patrick Corrigan, Northern Ireland programme director at Amnesty, said: "Politicians in Northern Ireland who continue to block marriage rights for same-sex couples are like latter-day King Canutes, trying in vain to hold back the tide of equality."

Supporters of gay marriage held protests in Belfast and Londonderry last night to object to the use of a petition on such an issue.

The voting mechanism was incorporated into Assembly structures during the peace process to protect minority views.

Mr Corrigan said: "With politicians continuing to block equality, it is now inevitable that same-sex couples in Northern Ireland will take a legal challenge on the basis of inferior treatment with regards to the right to marry and found a family."

He added: "States may not discriminate with regards to the right to marry and found a family, on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity.

"That obligation is clear in international law. This means that marriage should be available to same-sex couples in Northern Ireland, just as it is now in England and Wales and will shortly be in Scotland."

But DUP MLA Peter Weir stood by the move.

"The DUP as a party support the traditional definition of marriage as one man and one woman, and we will use whatever parliamentary devices we have at our disposal to make sure that remains the case - so we make no apology in taking a strong stand to defend marriage."

The first gay marriages took place in England and Wales last month. Scotland passed a similar law in February and the first same-sex marriages are expected there in October.

In Northern Ireland, with a greater proportion of Catholic and Protestant churchgoers than other parts of the UK and arguably a more conservative social culture, any change to the law would prove highly controversial.

A referendum on the issue is likely to be held in the Republic of Ireland next year.

Sinn Fein Assembly member Caitriona Ruane said other jurisdictions were moving forward to ensure marriage equality for all.

"The North should not be left behind," she said.

"Giving all couples equal marriage rights under the law does not threaten anyone's beliefs, religious or otherwise. Churches are free to define marriage as they wish but the state has a duty to treat all citizens equally."

Yesterday, Catholic bishops urged politicians to reject "marriage equality" for same-sex partnerships in Northern Ireland while the Church of Ireland restated its opposition to any change to the traditional definition of marriage.

The Stormont Assembly motion tabled by Sinn Fein calls on the DUP Minister for Finance and Personnel, Simon Hamilton, to introduce legislation to guarantee that couples of any sex or gender identity receive equal benefit.

The motion also states that religious institutions should have the freedom to decide whether to conduct same-sex marriages.

Northern Ireland's Catholic hierarchy – led by Cardinal Sean Brady – have written to every MLA urging them to vote against same-sex marriage, writes Liam Clarke

The letter comes ahead of a Sinn Fein-sponsored motion to be debated at Stormont today.

A statement taking a similar line against gay marriage has been issued by the Church of Ireland.

The missive from the Catholic leaders says that marriage between men and women "is a fundamental building block of society which makes a unique and irreplaceable contribution to the common good. It is therefore deserving of special recognition and promotion by the State".

Aside from the pressure by Church leaders, it now seems impossible that the motion will pass.

The DUP confirmed it had lodged a petition of concern, requiring that the motion be passed by a majority of unionist and nationalist members counted separately.

Since the DUP has most unionist MLAs this means it can block the motion regardless of other parties. DUP whip Peter Weir pointed out that, when the issue was twice debated at Stormont, it was defeated by a simple majority.

He maintained: "Same sex marriage is not an issue of equality or human rights and the Northern Ireland Assembly is entirely entitled to take a view on the issue."

The Sinn Fein motion attempts to allay religious sensitivities. It "supports freedom of religion by allowing religious institutions to define, observe and practise marriage according to their beliefs, granting them the freedom whether or not to conduct same-sex marriages".

Equality law would guarantee couples the right to marry in civil ceremonies without religious trappings.

The Church of Ireland issued its own statement quoting a motion passed by its General Synod in May 2012. It stated: "Marriage is part of God's creation and a holy mystery in which one man and one woman become one flesh ... the Church of Ireland recognises for itself and of itself, no other understanding of marriage."

Sinn Fein's Caitriona Ruane said: "Giving couples equal marriage rights under the law does not threaten anyone's beliefs, religious or otherwise. Churches are free to define marriage as they wish but the State has a duty to treat citizens equally."


Northern Ireland is the only part of the UK or Ireland which has no plans for legalising same-sex marriage. In England and Wales, the first same-sex marriages took place last month and in Scotland they are scheduled for autumn.

In the Republic there will be a referendum on the issue next year, with the main parties supporting change.

Here, same-sex marriages will be recognised only as civil partnerships. Two previous attempts to change the law at Stormont were defeated.

Belfast Telegraph


From Belfast Telegraph