| 4.1°C Belfast

Child heart unit probe to be held


Steve and Yolanda Turner, whose son Sean died from a brain haemorrhage after surgery at Bristol's Children Hospital

Steve and Yolanda Turner, whose son Sean died from a brain haemorrhage after surgery at Bristol's Children Hospital

Steve and Yolanda Turner, whose son Sean died from a brain haemorrhage after surgery at Bristol's Children Hospital

An independent review is to be held into a hospital's paediatric cardiac unit following concern about its treatment of newborn babies and young children who died or suffered complications.

Professor Sir Bruce Keogh, medical director of NHS England, confirmed the inquiry will take place at Bristol Children's Hospital, which is accused of a catalogue of neglect and mistreatment of babies and children with heart problems.

He said Sir Ian Kennedy, a lawyer who specialises in the law and ethics of healthcare, has agreed in principle to oversee the review.

Sir Bruce said in a statement yesterday: "We have today had a very important meeting with the families of children who died at Bristol.

"My deputy medical director Mike Bewick and I have listened with great care to their concerns about the care their children received.

"I would like to thank them for the dignified and powerful way they have talked to us.

"We collectively concluded that the most effective course of action might be to put in place an independent review of the care at the Trust's paediatric cardiac unit.

"It was clear that, in the interests of everyone, such a review would need to be independent of the NHS. It must be led by the families involved. It must be their review.

"I have already taken soundings from Sir Ian Kennedy who has agreed in principle to take such a review forward should the families wish him to do. I will now ask Sir Ian to meet the families and to work with them to see if they can come to the scope and terms of reference that the families want."

Last year it emerged around 10 families were believed to be taking legal action against the t rust, including seven whose children died following treatment at the hospital.

Previously some had spoken out about the ''inept care'' of the young patients and called for a public inquiry into what they considered to be ''chronically low standards''.

Among parents that have complained are Steve and Yolanda Turner, whose son Sean Turner died in March 2012 from a brain haemorrhage after previously suffering a cardiac arrest - six weeks after he underwent vital corrective heart surgery at the hospital.

Just last month at an inquest into his death they gave harrowing accounts o f how they begged doctors and nurses on Ward 32 to help their desperately ill son.

Mr and Mrs Turner, from Warminster, Wiltshire, claim their son's death was not isolated and other children with heart problems have died at the hospital.

They claim ward hygiene was poor, staff were incompetent and that Sean was neglected to the point where he had an avoidable cardiac arrest.

They came forward publicly after being struck by the similarities of Sean's death to an earlier tragedy. Cardiff youngster Luke Jenkins, seven, was expected to make a full recovery after successful corrective surgery at the hospital, but died after suffering a cardiac arrest on a bank holiday within a week of his operation.

His heart stopped for 43 minutes before he was resuscitated, after which he underwent exploratory surgery. He died the following day.

His death in April 2012 was due in part to the duty surgeon having to be urgently called in from home on Good Friday when Luke collapsed, something admitted by hospital bosses.

Junior nursing staff lost vital time because they did not know where resuscitation equipment was kept, it later emerged.

The emergency team was also unfamiliar with the equipment because cardiac arrest was rare in the ward environment, the hospital claimed.

In both cases the children were transferred from the intensive care unit to Ward 32 too rapidly, according to their parents.

Both sets of relatives believe that, but for substandard after-surgery care on the ward, their children would be alive.

Both claim that once on the ward they were increasingly anxious at the reduced level of care they felt their children received.

But they said that in both cases rising concerns were dismissed by ward staff who appeared too busy and too few to care properly for patients.

A spokesman for University Hospitals Bristol NHS Foundation Trust said it welcomed the review and hoped it would "restore trust and confidence in the service, which has learnt much from the experiences of these families".

The trust's acting chief executive Deborah Lee said: "It is very positive that the families who have raised concerns will be at the heart of shaping this review and our aim now is to work in partnership with them and Sir Ian Kennedy to demonstrate the safety and quality of the service, and to address any residual concerns that the review may highlight.

"For the families who continue to rely on our service, and the staff who work continue committedly to deliver the very best care, it is critical to remind ourselves that this service is delivering good clinical outcomes and, importantly, a positive experience for families - in our most recent survey of parents 98% said they had received excellent, very good or good care.

"It saddens me greatly that we have a group of families that believe we have let them down and we will continue to do our utmost to ensure that no other family experiences care in our services in the way that these families did."