Belfast Telegraph

Home News UK

English MPs' powers set for reform

English MPs would have the power to kick out Government bills under plans announced by William Hague to tackle the "crucial" issue of English votes for English laws.

The Commons leader s et out three proposals put forward by the Conservatives to reform the way laws currently progress through Parliament.

Under the most radical option, English MPs would have a separate vote in which they could veto an legislation - forcing the Government either to abandon the proposals or make changes to secure majority support.

Another option would mean English-only bills would go to an English-only grand committee at second reading and the remaining stages would be governed by a convention that means MPs from other nations would not vote.

A final option sets out plans that would allow only English MPs to consider the amending stages of legislation that relates only to England but the final vote would be open to all MPs.

All three proposals would involve Welsh MPs where legislation also relates to Wales.

The Conservatives insist the process must still be introduced in parallel to plans for further devolution to Scotland as a "matter of fairness".

Mr Hague told the Commons: " This is a fundamental issue of fairness for all the people of the United Kingdom. Just as the people of Scotland will have more power over their affairs, so it follows the people of England, Wales and Northern Ireland must have the opportunity to have a bigger say over theirs."

In a separate proposal set out in the command paper, the Liberal Democrats called for English MPs at Westminster to have a "stronger voice and a stronger veto" over purely English-only issues.

The party wants any new stage introduced into the process, such as a grand committee of English MPs, to be drawn up to reflect the number of votes cast for each party in England rather than how many parliamentary seats it has.

Any measures which "unambiguously affect" England only should be subject to a new parliamentary stage with the power to veto proposals.

That would mean English voters can be sure that decisions that affect only England cannot be imposed on them by a minority of English MPs along with MPs from Scotland, the Lib Dems said.

Labour boycotted talks under Mr Hague, claiming the process was a "stitch-up".

Barring Scottish MPs from parts of the legislative process could leave the party struggling to push through legislation, even if it wins a majority, because much of its power base is north of the border.

Mr Hague accused Labour of being "hostile" for refusing to join the talks or submit proposals to be published in the paper.

The Conservatives will make an announcement about which one of the options they will support in the new year.


From Belfast Telegraph