Holyrood approves smacking ban on ‘momentous day for children’s rights’
Children’s campaigners have hailed the change in the law in Scotland.
Scotland’s ban on smacking has been passed on what has been hailed as a “momentous day for children’s rights”.
Children’s campaigners were amongst those who welcomed the passage of the Children (Equal Protection from Assault) (Scotland) Bill at Holyrood.
The legislation, brought forward by Green MSP John Finnie, gives children the same protection from violence as adults by removing the defence of justifiable assault in Scots law.
It will come into force within 12 months of the Bill gaining Royal Assent.
Sweden became the first country in the world to ban smacking in the home when it outlawed corporal punishment in 1979 – with Scotland now the 58th nation to do so.
Scotland’s Children’s Commissioner Bruce Adamson welcomed the move, saying: “Assaulting a child for the purpose of punishment should never be legal and this important law change brings Scotland into line with its international human rights commitment to provide children with comprehensive legal protection from violence.”
Dunja Mijatovic, the commissioner of human rights at the Council of Europe, also welcomed the vote.
I congratulate the Scottish Parliament for adopting the law to give children equal protection from assault. There is no place for violence in a child's life. This law is a good step towards the full realisation of children’s rights in the country. #SPEqualProtection @ScotParl— Commissioner for Human Rights (@CommissionerHR) October 3, 2019
She tweeted: “I congratulate the Scottish Parliament for adopting the law to give children equal protection from assault. There is no place for violence in a child’s life. This law is a good step towards the full realisation of children’s rights in the country.”
Joanna Barrett, of NSPCC Scotland, said: “This historic vote delivers a UK first in fairness and equality for children which the NSPCC has long championed.
“It’s a common sense move that closes an archaic loophole and ensures that, finally, children in Scotland will have the same protection from assault as adults.”
Martin Crewe, director of Barnardo’s Scotland, described it as “a momentous day for children’s rights”.
He thanked Mr Finnie for his “dedication and passion” in pushing the Bill forward, and said: “We look forward to seeing similar legislation passed in the Welsh Assembly and hope that this progress can be mirrored across the other nations of the UK too.”
🎉IT’S PASSED!!🎉@ScotParl has passed the Children (Equal Protection from Assault)(Scotland) Bill.— NSPCC Scotland (@NSPCC_Scotland) October 3, 2019
An historic day for children in Scotland.
Delighted to be there to witness this significant vote w/ our partners @children1st @BarnardosScot @CYPCS #SPEqualProtection
Mary Glasgow, chief executive of the charity Children 1st, said: “This is a defining moment for Scotland.
“Again and again people have told us about the lifelong impact of being hit as a child, as they’ve joined the campaign to change the law.
“Today’s vote protects every future generation of Scotland’s children from any and all levels of physical violence. Families will be stronger and communities will be safer.
“Once again Scotland is leading the rest of the UK in doing what’s right for children – our most precious and vulnerable citizens.”
Medical professionals and religious leaders also welcomed the Bill, which was passed by 84 votes to 29.
Professor Steve Turner, of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, said: “The Scottish Parliament has ensured equal protection for children across Scotland from assault.
“Scotland is the first country in the UK to provide children with the same rights as adults – it is not legally justifiable to use violence against adults, it will not be for children either.”
Richard Frazer, convener of the Church of Scotland’s Church and Society Council, said: “The passage of this Bill gives children the same legal protection as adults, acknowledging that children are valuable as they are and not simply as adults in training.
“We hope that the positive change marked today will enable children and families to continue to flourish and grow as equal members of our communities.”
#SPEqualProtection Hugely proud of Human Rights Guarantors of @ScotParl, Human Rights Leader @JohnFinnieHI, and all the Human Rights Defenders young and old who have long campaigned for this - SCOTLAND WILL HAVE EQUAL PROTECTION for children from physical punishment.— Bruce Adamson (@Bruce_Adamson) October 3, 2019
The Law Society of Scotland stressed that now the Bill has been approved, the Scottish Government must mount a “comprehensive campaign” to raise awareness of the change in the law.
Morag Driscoll, the organisation’s family law committee convener, said: “The reasonable chastisement defence attracted criticism from international children’s rights organisations. However, Scotland is now sending a clear message that all forms of assault against children are unacceptable.
“Driving meaningful behavioural change requires much more than changing the law. The Scottish Government now needs to launch a comprehensive public education and awareness campaign to alert people to these changes.”