PM backs under-pressure Tory chairman and chief whip in Brexit voting row
Theresa May said Brandon Lewis and Julian Smith made an ‘honest mistake’ over ‘pairing’ during a key Brexit vote, amid calls for them both to resign.
Conservative chief whip Julian Smith and Tory chairman Brandon Lewis have been backed by Theresa May in the face of intense pressure on them to quit in a row over claims they adopted murky tactics during a crucial Brexit vote.
The Prime Minister insisted the two men had made an “honest mistake” after it emerged the failure to keep to a voting “pairing” pact was actually planned rather than an “error” as claimed.
A Tory former minister joined Labour in calling for the men’s resignations, while backbench Conservative MP Heidi Allen said she had challenged Mr Smith about the incident and he was “unable to confirm” that he did not order the breaking of the pact.
I’m sorry Jo. I think it was an honest mistake made by the whips in fast-moving circumstances. I know how important the pair is to everyone, especially new parents, and I apologise. Also apologies for late reply, been speaking at an event.— Brandon Lewis (@BrandonLewis) July 17, 2018
Mrs May, who faces calls to apologise for misleading MPs about what happened, was told she must sack the two men if they did not go voluntarily.
But speaking to the Press Association during a visit to Northern Ireland on Thursday, she said: “An honest mistake was made here and both the chief whip and Brandon Lewis have apologised to Jo Swinson, the member for East Dunbartonshire about that.
“As I say, it was an honest mistake and they have apologised.”
The decision to deploy dark arts tactics during the knife-edge vote on Tuesday drew criticism from across the political divide.
I regret to inform that despite repeatedly asking Julian Smith direct questions this afternoon, he has been unable to confirm to me that he did not give instructions to break pairs. Therefore I can only conclude MPs were told to break pairs on Tuesday 1/2— Heidi Allen MP (@heidiallen75) July 19, 2018
When I became an MP in 2015, I was determined to challenge stereotypes about politicians. I refuse to be tarnished by this behaviour so will not stand by and say nothing. Integrity and honesty are fundamental to our democracy. Anything less is unacceptable 2/2— Heidi Allen MP (@heidiallen75) July 19, 2018
Labour Party chairman Ian Lavery said: “The Tories’ story is changing by the minute as they desperately scramble to cover up their appalling actions.
“This Government is rotten to its core. Julian Smith and Brandon Lewis must now resign or be sacked, and Theresa May must apologise for misleading the House.”
Tory former minister Anna Soubry, a leading Remainer, said: “If true, this is appalling and those responsible must resign. If we cannot behave with honour we are nothing.”
Conservative Brexiteer Peter Bone said he was “very concerned” to hear that a pairing had been broken.
Ms Allen said: “Despite repeatedly asking Julian Smith direct questions this afternoon, he has been unable to confirm to me that he did not give instructions to break pairs.
“Therefore I can only conclude MPs were told to break pairs on Tuesday.
“When I became an MP in 2015, I was determined to challenge stereotypes about politicians.
“I refuse to be tarnished by this behaviour so will not stand by and say nothing. Integrity and honesty are fundamental to our democracy.
“Anything less is unacceptable.”
Just how low will your govt stoop @theresa_may? When @andrealeadsom delayed proxy voting motions, she *assured* those of us who were pregnant that we would be paired when necessary. Today your govt broke that agreement - @BrandonLewis paired with me but voted. Desperate stuff. pic.twitter.com/CcgF7z8MOV— Jo Swinson (@joswinson) July 17, 2018
Mr Lewis had been “paired” with Liberal Democrat deputy leader Jo Swinson, meaning neither would walk through the voting lobbies.
Mrs May told MPs the breaking of the pair was “done in error”.
But The Times reported that the party chairman and two other Tory MPs were told by Mr Smith that they should go ahead and vote despite being paired.
It said the two unnamed MPs both sought further advice and ignored the instruction.
The Conservative Party did not deny the allegations.
Ms Swinson said: “Well … This reflects pretty badly on those peddling the ‘honest mistake’ nonsense.
“To be fair, hats off to the two MPs who told their chief whip to take a running jump when he asked them to break a pairing just because the govt might lose.”
The actions did not change the result of the votes but the Government only narrowly scraped through.
Downing Street said Mrs May still had full confidence in Mr Smith.
Lib Dems called for the chief whip to make a statement to the House.
SNP Westminster leader Pete Wishart asked in the Commons for a full inquiry into the breakdown of pairing.
A Conservative spokesman said: “We have apologised for the fact that a pregnancy pairing arrangement was broken in error this week.
“No other pairs offered on the Trade Bill on Tuesday were broken.”
Commons Leader Andrea Leadsom said there would now be a debate on proxy voting, which would end the need for pairing, in September.
Over the course of the Parliament, 66 pairing arrangements have been broken, with 52 of those at the hands of the Opposition, according to Tory sources.
Conservative whips did consider breaking short-term pairing arrangements – those for MPs who need to be away for another engagement, sources acknowledged.
But they said long-term pairing for maternity and health issues was something they stick to and insisted breaking the agreement with Ms Swinson had been a mistake.
It is understood that is the error the PM referred to when she spoke to MPs about the issue.