Belfast Telegraph

Home News UK

Police to contest 'kettling' ruling

Police are to appeal against a High Court decision declaring unlawful controversial "kettling" tactics used against demonstrators during G20 protests in central London two years ago.

The judgment led to a call from human rights lawyers for an "immediate change to police attitudes and tactics".

But the Metropolitan Police expressed concern over the impact of the ruling on its ability "to prevent disorder within protests".

The judgment was a victory for student Hannah McClure and Josh Moos, a campaigner for Plane Stupid, who had challenged the legality of the "violent" restraint methods used against them at the Camp for Climate Action in Bishopsgate on April 1 2009. It was the day newspaper seller Ian Tomlinson died after being struck by a police officer at a separate G20 protest at the nearby Royal Exchange.

The police had sought to justify imposing the kettle at the climate camp, saying they feared violent demonstrators at the Royal Exchange would "hijack" the more peaceful climate camp, attended by up to 4,000 people.

But the High Court ruled on Thursday there had been no evidence of an imminent breach of the peace to justify the kettle, in which a tight police cordon was thrown round the demonstrators from just after 7pm for more than four hours.

The judges criticised "unduly inflexible" arrangements for releasing people contained within it. Moos said he became dehydrated after being refused permission to leave. The judges specifically condemned the Metropolitan Police over the way officers armed with batons and riot shields pushed a 15-deep crowd of demonstrators back some 20m-30m.

The Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) announced it would appeal against the judgment, saying: "It should be noted that the judgment relates to the individual circumstances of April 1 2009 and not the use of containment at other events. Where necessary, we will continue to use containment as a last resort to prevent serious disorder and violence.

"However, we believe that this issue is so important for the police's ability to prevent disorder within protest that we will be appealing the Administrative Court's finding that the containment and pushing operations on the April 1 2009 in Bishopsgate were not lawful.

"The MPS believes that the Bishopsgate containment prevented further scenes of violence and criminal damage occurring on April 1 2009."


From Belfast Telegraph