Belfast Telegraph

Home News World

Marathon bomb trial stays in Boston

A judge has granted a two-month trial delay for Boston Marathon bombing suspect Dzhokhar Tsarnaev, but refused to move his trial.

Judge George O'Toole ruled that the trial would begin on January 5 instead of November 3, but said there was no reason to assume in advance that a fair jury could not be selected in Massachusetts.

Defence lawyers wanted the trial to be moved to Washington DC, citing extensive media coverage in Boston and evaluations of public sentiment by their experts.

They also asked for a trial delay until at least September 2015, saying they had not time to prepare for a November trial and had been given less time than was granted in many other federal death penalty cases.

Tsarnaev, 21, who has pleaded not guilty to 30 federal charges, could face the death penalty if convicted.

Prosecutors say he and his older brother placed two pressure cooker bombs that exploded near the marathon's finish line. Three people were killed and more than 260 injured. Tamerlan Tsarnaev, 26, died in a shootout with police several days later.

"Although media coverage in this case has been extensive, at this stage the defendant has failed to show that it has so inflamed and pervasively prejudiced the pool that a fair and impartial jury cannot be empanelled in this district," Judge O'Toole wrote.

He also said a short delay was warranted because of the large amount of evidence the defence received from prosecutors. But he said: "An additional delay of 10 months as requested by the defendant does not appear necessary."

Prosecutors and defence lawyerss agreed they would need to summon about 2,000 potential jurors, but they filed more than 100 pages of legal briefs arguing over moving the trial.

The judge agreed with prosecutors' arguments that the defence's expert evaluations were flawed and that eastern Massachusetts' diverse population of more than five million was sufficient to pick a jury.

The defence has cited the trial of Oklahoma City bomber Timothy McVeigh, which was moved to Denver, Colorado, saying the marathon bombing had an even broader emotional impact.

But Judge O'Toole said a more pertinent example was the supreme court's upholding of the decision not to move the 2006 trial of Enron fraud defendant Jeffrey Skilling from Houston, Texas, a similar large venue where feelings and publicity about that case were strong.

Boston has recently held several high-profile federal trials, including that of Boston mobster James "Whitey" Bulger, the judge noted. In each case, he said, jurors returned mixed verdicts indicating they had carefully evaluated trial evidence.

"It is doubtful whether a jury could be selected anywhere in the country whose members were wholly unaware of the Marathon bombings. The constitution does not oblige them to be," he said.


From Belfast Telegraph