Belfast Telegraph

Scottish referendum: Alex Salmond failed to break up our family of nations

By Nelson McCausland

Last week's column was the last one written while I was Minister for Social Development. Today I have my first meeting as the new chair of the Culture, Arts and Leisure Committee. Naturally I have reflected on what I have achieved over the past three years in DSD and I will return to that next week. It has been a privilege to serve in the Northern Ireland Executive over the past five years, in DCAL and then DSD, and a privilege for which I am very grateful.

Today, though, I wish to reflect upon the poll in Scotland. The people there have spoken and they have wiped the smile off the face of Alex Salmond. Scotland has determined that it will remain within the family of nations that is the United Kingdom. As Johann Lamont, the Scottish Labour leader, has said, the United Kingdom is now the "settled will" of the Scottish people. Salmond is a canny politician but he failed to convince a majority of Scottish people that independence was a better way forward.

As we celebrate the result of the referendum and the fact that the family has not been fractured, there are nevertheless some issues that need to be addressed.

During the campaign Alex Salmond said that the referendum would settle the matter for "a lifetime" but since his defeat he seems at times to have reneged on that. It is clear that he and the SNP are struggling to come to terms with the will of the people. Salmond has been bitter and truculent and his truculence has demeaned and diminished him personally.

Moreover, if he and his party continue in this way they will damage the nation that they profess to love. That would not be good for the Scottish people.

Of course it is worth remembering that at one time Salmond was a leading member of the 79 Group, which was formed in 1979 as a pressure group within the SNP and was dedicated to a "socialist and republican Scotland". He has achieved much but ultimately he has failed to deliver either a socialist Scotland or a republican Scotland.

There was a clear majority for the Union but the majority could and should have been even greater. Unfortunately for much of the time the Better Together campaign was lacklustre. It lacked the passion of the independence campaign and that was illustrated in the weak and wooden performance of Alistair Darling. It was only at the end that Gordon Brown appeared on the scene with some powerful and passionate speeches. Brown got it in a way that Darling didn't.

The independence campaign was directed at the heart whereas the campaign for the Union was directed at the head. Only latterly did the Better Together campaign start to speak to the heart as well as the head. Monetary arguments really matter but for many people national pride and sense of identity matter as well. I was waiting to hear the case for the Union in those terms but for much of the campaign I didn't hear it.

That is something that deserves careful consideration. Britishness should not be taken for granted; it is something that should be nourished in the same way that other identities are nourished. The things that bind us together should be celebrated and the bonds should be strengthened. I really hope that in the rush to produce some agreement on greater devolution for Scotland that issue is not forgotten.

The campaign also exposed a sense of alienation towards Westminster and I suspect that many people who voted for independence were really taking the opportunity to express their alienation from what is sometimes described as the "Westminster elite". That alienation is not restricted to Scotland. It can be found in many parts of England as well, especially in the Midlands and the North of England. They believe that the government is too London-centric with little appreciation of the problems and the issues faced by people in less affluent areas further north. Westminster should take note!

Finally, during the campaign I noticed many badges and posters with the words "aye" and "naw". Quite a number of campaigners on both sides used the Scots words to express their position and there was even a website entitled 'Scotland says Naw'. I was pleased therefore to see that there was no mockery from the media towards Scots words or the Scots language and perhaps some people here in Ulster could learn a lesson from that.

Scottish Independence Vote further reading

Scottish independence: Publicans really nail their colours to the mast 

Scottish independence: Battle between Yes and No takes a bitter twist in final hours of campaigning

Scottish independence: No camp drowned out by noisy, flamboyant and abrasive rivals who sense historic win 

Scottish independence: Break-up of the Union could hit Northern Ireland, warn business chiefs

Scottish independence: Ties that bind Northern Ireland and Scotland go way back and will survive the referendum 

Scottish independence: From oil and the pound to the Queen and tax - everything you need to know about the referendum

Will Rod Stewart abandon his love for Scotland? Will the Krankies sing for their country at Eurovision? And what would independence mean for Northern Ireland?

Scotland votes: Forget Izzard, David Bowie and Beckham - Scots shouldn't look to the stars for a decision on its future

Scotland referendum Yes vote would be a massive No, insists Danske Bank

Scottish independence: Breaking up would be a painful divorce, warns Cameron

Scottish referendum: Focus on devolved tax powers issue whatever Scottish result 

Scottish independence: David Beckham joins 'No' campaign urging voters to save the Union

Scottish independence: Unionists must change tack to save the Union

Scottish independence: Queen 'hopes voters think carefully' over Union vote

Scottish referendum a chance to send Tories a message

Scottish independence: Storm over Lord Dannatt's 'betrayal of soldiers' comments

Scottish independence: Yes vote supporters attack BBC over pro-Union 'bias'

The Queen hopes Scots will ''think very carefully'' before voting in the independence referendum

Orange Order calls for 'No' vote in Scottish independence referendum at Edinburgh rally 

Queen will not be dragged into Scottish independence debate, Palace warns No camp

Scots independence referendum result too close to call 

Scottish independence: Unionists in Northern Ireland can expect a border poll of their own in the not-too-distant future

Westminster elite in a panic as more voters are backing Scottish independence, says Alex Salmond

UK is the envy of the world, David Cameron tells Scots

Scottish independence: Scotland is only have to watch Braveheart or read the 1707 Act of Union to see how different

Orange Order staging march in Edinburgh in support of Union: Thousands due at parade ahead of Scottish referendum

Scottish independence: Just days to go in one of the longest political campaigns in history 

Scottish 'yes' is a big no, no according to Peter Scudamore

Scottish independence: Whether Yes or No, we can learn lessons from the Scots

Shift towards Yes camp up by 38% as campaigns neck-and-neck according to TNS Scotland survey

Gordon Brown makes devolution vow in bid to spike Yes campaign guns 

Economist warns Scotland 'to be afraid of independence'

Scottish Referendum: Wait and see the outcome before dealing with any implications, says Martin McGuinness

No and Yes neck and neck, poll says

Scottish independence: Yes vote would have repercussions on border control

Scotland swings to Yes but Alex Salmond isn't resting on his laurels

Scots offered more powers if they reject independence

Pro-independence Yes campaign leads polls for first time in Scottish referendum battle

Scottish independence: Logic of staying in United Kingdom is slow to sink in 

Scottish independence: A matter for the head and heart

Referendum outcome won't affect us - SDC Trailers aims to stay close to hauliers

Scotland independence could bring tax breaks for North Sea oil industry

Alistair Darling: Scottish independence referendum will go right to the wire

Scottish independence: Trade and cultural links too strong to ever break

Scottish referendum: London sells us short in buying No vote 

Independence: What's the next step for Scotland and how will Northern Ireland people living there vote?

Belfast Telegraph


From Belfast Telegraph