Dawn Astle urges players to back call to replace Gordon Taylor as PFA boss
But former PFA chairman Pat Nevin says Gordon Taylor’s contribution to the players’ union should not be overlooked just because of his high salary.
The daughter of former West Brom and England star Jeff Astle has “begged” members of the Professional Footballers’ Association to support its chairman Ben Purkiss’ attempt to oust chief executive Gordon Taylor.
Dawn Astle, whose father died in 2002 of a degenerative brain disease, has repeatedly clashed with Taylor over the union’s response to the growing evidence which suggests that disease is linked to heading the ball.
Last year, the PFA finally agreed to commit £100,000 for research into the matter, but this was less than 5 per cent of Taylor’s 2017 pay of £2.2million and less than 1 per cent of its annual income of nearly £28million.
I have a duty to act in the best interests of the PFA. Sometimes you have to make a stand for what is right. Football is rapidly evolving, players are rapidly evolving and the PFA needs to evolve too. Players past, present and future need a PFA for the modern player.— Ben Purkiss (@bpurkiss23) November 15, 2018
Those huge discrepancies are just two of the issues Purkiss has raised since becoming PFA chairman last November.
In a tweet sent last week, the 34-year-old Walsall defender wrote he has a “duty to act in the best interests of the PFA” and “sometimes you have to make a stand for what is right”. He added that football and footballers are “rapidly evolving and the PFA needs to evolve too”.
With this in mind, the law graduate has called for an independent review of the union and, according to reports, this call has been backed by more than 200 former and current players.
The PFA has noted the press reports published last night relating to an issue it currently faces regarding the eligibility of Ben Purkiss.— PFA | Professional Footballers' Association (@PFA) November 16, 2018
Full statement here: https://t.co/7XgpAM4Kvo
The PFA, on the other hand, issued a statement on Friday questioning Purkiss’ right to union membership, and therefore his eligibility to be chairman, as he is not under contract at Walsall.
Speaking to Press Association Sport, Astle said: “I would ask, no, beg, all PFA members to fully support what Ben is trying to do.
“The PFA needs reform and it needs to have people in charge who really care about the most important issues facing players, and dementia is one of those.”
Press Association Sport has contacted Purkiss and Taylor for comment.
Taylor, who turns 74 next month, has run the union since 1981, during which time he has strongly defended his members’ right to earn large salaries from the game. More controversially, however, he has also earned himself massive sums while doing so and is, by some margin, the best-paid union official in Britain.
His pay is more in line with what the bosses of the players’ associations in American sport earn and has been rising ever since he threatened a US-style players’ strike in 2001.
The peace deal agreed then by the outgoing Premier League boss Richard Scudamore has seen the PFA take a percentage of the league’s TV income to spend on looking after former players, funding courses, helping current players with problems, contributing to good causes and paying its staff.
Former Chelsea, Everton and Scotland winger Pat Nevin was PFA chairman between 1993 and 1997, when he also sat on the union’s pension committee, and he remembers “long and complex” negotiations with Taylor about his remuneration.
Nevin, who now works as a pundit for the BBC, told PA Sport that Taylor believed he was worth the amount he was paid because of how much money he made the union – money that enabled it to provide significant services for its past and present members.
The 55-year-old, who later had a stint as Motherwell’s chief executive, said his prime concern as PFA chairman was always to make sure it could afford Taylor’s pay and pension liability.
But he said there was a real chance at the time that Taylor could have been poached and admitted that the union boss had been crucial to setting up its “fantastic” pension schemes.
“I’m not here to defend or support Gordon – he is paid a large salary and that will always be a stick to hit him with – but I know the union does a lot more than it gets the credit for,” said Nevin.
“I think this is typical of public life. If you do 25 good things and one bad thing, you can bet which thing it is you will be reading about.”