Belfast Telegraph

Jose Mourinho not fit to take place of Sir Alex at Manchester United

By Frank Malley

A lot of people would welcome back Jose Mourinho to the Premier League tomorrow. Some argue it has missed his colourful presence. Some, Chelsea fans predominantly, believe it needs his winning mentality.

Others, mainly in the media, miss the easy quotes and ready storylines which come with a character who is a walking, talking, squabbling, posturing blend of arrogance and charm.

Yet a lot of people would be wrong. The Premier League is better off without Mourinho. All the evidence to support that statement was demonstrated before, during and after Real Madrid's 2-0 semi-final first-leg defeat at home to Barcelona in the Champions League when Mourinho proved he is not fit to take the job he covets — namely succeeding Sir Alex Ferguson as manager at Manchester United.

Okay, Mourinho's apologists will say, what was so different about his behaviour to that of Ferguson?

After all, Ferguson regularly indulges in mind games, just as Mourinho did when he launched a calculated attack on Barcelona coach Pep Guardiola for ‘criticising correct decisions of referees' in the pre-match press conference.

Ferguson is no stranger to being sent from the touchline as Mourinho was in the Bernabeu. In fact, Ferguson has only just completed a five-match ban.

Neither is Ferguson averse to a conspiracy theory, although Mourinho's post-match assertion that Barcelona receive favourable treatment from referees and that the club had yet to win a “clean” Champions League title under Pep Guardiola was clearly risible.

Mourinho is a graceless loser but neither is he alone there in a profession in which good losers invariably find themselves queueing at the Jobcentre.

We could pick holes in Mourinho's character all day but it was the lack of courage in his footballing tactics which marked him down as a man who would struggle to fill Ferguson's chair.

Could you imagine Manchester United fans, weaned on swashbuckling football, standing for their manager playing what amounted to a 4-6-0 formation at home in the most important match of the season? No, neither can I.

True, Barcelona are the world's best footballing side, but Real Madrid have attacking players, too, players of pace and imagination in the finest traditions of the club which once dominated Europe.

For much of the semi-final Mourinho kept them on a chain, like guard dogs, snapping and yelping at Barcelona's talent but yanked back sharply if they dared venture as far as the halfway line. A goalless draw the pinnacle of their ambition.

Where is the style in that? Where is the recognition of a great club's principles? Where is the duty to the game of football? Where is the honour? The truth is there was none.

Ferguson, if United face Barcelona at Wembley in the final on May 28 as now looks likely, doubtless would be cautious too.

He would not set up in a gung-ho formation, offering space to Barcelona on which they thrive.

Yet neither would he strap his best players in a straitjacket of caution, the sort which Roman Abramovich tired of with Mourinho at Chelsea.

Make no mistake, while Barcelona are not averse to a spat, Mourinho was the architect of a squalid, tetchy, ugly match which contained so much which brought shame on football.

How stark, too, was Mourinho's pragmatism when set against the beguiling individualism of Barcelona's Lionel Messi.

Is Messi the best footballer who ever lived? Gordon Strachan, commentating for television, believed he was after seeing him score both goals, the second in the finest dribbling traditions of his Argentine predecessor Diego Maradona.

Such comparisons are unscientific and largely meaningless. What is beyond doubt, however, is that Messi plays the game with a verve and a bravery and a magic which is unparalleled.

There is no over-elaboration or selfishness in the manner of Real's Cristiano Ronaldo. Messi is the ultimate team player as well as the sublime individual.

It is a potent blend.

The Premier League would be fortunate and proud to have him. Could the same really be said of Mourinho?

Belfast Telegraph

Daily News Headlines Newsletter

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox.


From Belfast Telegraph