Belfast Telegraph

Home Sport Rugby

Hartley could face World Cup exile

Dylan Hartley's participation in the World Cup has been plunged into grave doubt after the England hooker was cited for an unprovoked headbutt in his club's Aviva Premiership semi-final.

Hartley thrust his head into the face of opposite number Jamie George during an off-the-ball incident that unfolded in the moments after Northampton had scored a try through Tom Wood in their 29-24 defeat by Saracens at Franklin's Gardens on Saturday.

George appeared to be unsighted at the time and the incident provoked an angry response from several Saracens players, but neither referee Greg Garner nor the television match official took action despite viewing replays.

Hartley must appear before a Rugby Football Union disciplinary panel in Coventry on Wednesday evening and with the entry point sanction for the offence starting at four weeks, his involvement in England 2015 is under serious threat.

"Dylan Hartley was cited following the Premiership semi-final match between Northampton Saints and Saracens for striking an opponent with his head, contrary to Law 10.4(a)," a Rugby Football Union statement read.

Hartley has an appalling disciplinary record having missed virtually an entire year of his career - 50 weeks - through suspensions incurred for a range of offences including gouging, biting and abusing a referee.

If the hearing sees the 29-year-old Northampton captain found guilty, disciplinary regulations state that any ban must include matches.

The minimum sanction of four weeks would mean he misses all three warm-up games for the World Cup, starting with France's visit to Twickenham on August 15.

England head coach Stuart Lancaster would have to consider the wisdom of picking a player who would have been inactive since May in his final 31-man squad for the tournament.

Further muddying the waters is whether Lancaster finally loses patience with his most capped international and opts to send the front row into Red Rose exile.

As recently as December, Hartley was sent off for use of the elbow against Leicester, and having served the ensuing three-week ban he was then dispatched to the sin-bin for tackling on the ground in his comeback game against Racing Metro.

Two years ago, after he had been forced to miss the British and Irish Lions tour to Australia as punishment for abusing referee Wayne Barnes in the Premiership final, Hartley accepted any more indiscretions would be terminal for his England career.

"I understand he (Lancaster) can't keep giving me a chance. People can't keep giving me a chance and I am basically on my last chance in that set-up. That is fully understood," Hartley said at the time.

Lancaster recently adopted a strong disciplinary stance on Manu Tuilagi, suspending the centre until January after he was found guilty by a magistrates' court of assaulting a taxi driver and two female police officers.

The damning footage of Hartley's assault on George means Lancaster has been placed in a difficult position once again, with the setback of losing his first-choice hooker weighed against the backlash he may face for giving Hartley yet another chance.

In a twist of fate, it is George who would benefit if Hartley were to be withdrawn from World Cup contention.

Saracens director of rugby Mark McCall insists George should have been included in the training squad recently named by England after an outstanding campaign.

"Jamie was massively unlucky to miss out on the squad," McCall said.

"I understand Hartley and Tom Youngs are experienced and deserve to be there and Luke Cowan-Dickie is a player of real potential and has been picked on that basis, but Jamie has been the best hooker in the Premiership this season."


From Belfast Telegraph