Belfast Telegraph

Sports Awards

Home Sport Rugby

Townsend's high-risk strategy is a major concern for the Irish

By Tony Ward

Given how the structure has developed in the respective countries since the game went open, it is difficult for those of more tender years to comprehend that Ireland and Scotland were once joined at the hip.

The ability of the IRFU to embrace professionalism ahead of their counterparts in the SRU saw the game on this side of the Irish Sea surge forward at a rate of knots.

For sure the provincial system was made to measure for the professional game here while in Scotland they struggled in amalgamating clubs with the District system of old.

Even to this day I find it strange that the Borders (the heart of Scottish rugby and akin to the Valleys in Wales or Limerick here) have still no representative team alongside Edinburgh and Glasgow.

Against that has been the rise and rise of Glasgow Rugby. The city is still the Scottish hotbed of football but with oval ball up alongside the best in the European equivalent.

World Rugby needs Scottish Rugby to be back where it was prior to professionalism and signs are that it is happening. I am not privy to the internal workings of the SRU but the romantic, and I would like to think pragmatist, in me would like to see a Borders Rugby presence strengthen the Scottish game even further again.

And yes, we did have an attempt through the Border Reivers in the early Noughties.

If we in this part of the world can sustain four professional entities as consistently competitive as we are then surely three Districts instead of two, particularly given the history and tradition in the Borders, should represent a very real and achievable aspiration.

In Australia they stretched themselves too far too soon with five Super Rugby franchises but that has now been paired back to four with the Melbourne Rebels chosen ahead of the Western Force to drive the professional game alongside the Waratahs, Reds and Brumbies.

The Welsh too have cut back to four the number of Regions competing in Guinness PRO14 rugby but it would certainly seem from the outside that an increase in the Scottish professional presence from two to three would benefit the game in Scotland enormously and most certainly at the highest level.

Of course at the helm in Scottish Rugby at this point in time is Galashiels great Gregor Townsend. I expressed the view in relation to Conor Murray that as a player my respect holds no bounds.

In combining Townsend the player with time spent as former player coach (to the Reivers) and coach to the Warriors culminating in the top post in Scottish Rugby, here too my respect holds no bounds. As a player I loved Townsend's laissez faire, off-the-cuff approach.

As an out-half he was as unconventional and unpredictable as they come. I can identify with that and no, irrespective of criticism from many quarters, I wouldn't change it. 

But where Townsend has taken it to another level is in harnessing that inventive style and creating teams in his own image. That is some achievement in today's game of minimal space and claustrophobic defending.

Glasgow Warriors didn't just win the PRO12 (as it was then) but did so in style. Their total rugby when eclipsing Munster in the final at Kingspan was a joy to behold and paved the way for Connacht and the Scarlets to follow suit.

Bear in mind that apart from the land of his birth he played club rugby in England, France, South Africa and Australia. You cannot put a value on that knowledge or on the sacrifices made along the way to achieve it.

The moment of magic when he manufactured that reverse pass to Gavin Hastings to steal and seal a dramatic last-minute win against the French in Paris in '95 will live in Scottish minds forever and in many ways define his career for the intuitive genius he was, and I use that superlative deliberately.

Four years later in the 1999 Five Nations, he scored a try against each of the other four countries, becoming the first Scotsman in 75 years to achieve that feat. For Mark Ella read Gregor Townsend and vice versa.

Incidentally on the back of that famous Parisian reverse pass, it and he acquired the moniker 'Toonie Flip'. Joe Schmidt has many outstanding traits and preaches many constructive tactics through his players but when it comes to the Toonie Flip he and his Scottish counterparts occupy different planets.

High-risk rugby was once the French preserve but is now Scottish in Six Nations rights and execution. 

And bear in mind the main man's on-field commander in chief is cut from the same cloth. He could pick a Duncan Weir  type player to steer a steady course but in keeping with the weather there's not a snowball's hope in hell.

Finn Russell is made from the same stuff and has his head coach's full and unequivocal support to play the opposition and the game but not the plan.

I love everything that Townsend stands for. I love the fact that like Schmidt he opted not to go to New Zealand as a Warren Gatland sidekick, irrespective of the honour involved. He is a rarity. A former player, make that legendary player, who in coaching terms is not making good but great.

Few former playing greats with top-level coaching ambition succeed. I don't know why but for whatever reason that is fact.

There are exceptions but they are few and far between. To that end I would dearly like Ronan O'Gara to succeed given his desire and the overseas route (like Townsend) he is taking to acquire relevant knowledge.

With respect to Gatland, Graham Henry and coaches like Schmidt and Eddie Jones now in the mix, I wish every Lions coach was Saxon or Celtic born and raised. It is an idle dream. And if I'm honest, despite us having our best coach ever, I wish he was Irish.

Therein lies the challenge going forward but for now it's how to dismantle Russell and Townsend at the top of the Irish agenda.

Belfast Telegraph

Daily News Headlines Newsletter

Today's news headlines, directly to your inbox.


From Belfast Telegraph