Belfast Telegraph

Home Sport Rugby World Cup

How Stuart McCloskey's day got even worse while Ulster fans fume over Ireland World Cup squad omission

Ireland coach Joe Schmidt has left Stuart McCloskey (inset) out of his World Cup training panel, much to the disappointment of Ulster fans.
Ireland coach Joe Schmidt has left Stuart McCloskey (inset) out of his World Cup training panel, much to the disappointment of Ulster fans.
Gareth Hanna

By Gareth Hanna

While six Ulster players have been included in the Ireland training panel ahead of the World Cup, the main talking point for the northern province is the omission of Stuart McCloskey.

Rugby round up Newsletter

Game previews, plus expert insights and exclusive commentary from the Belfast Telegraph sports team.

The centre was named Ulster's Player of the Year and Supporters' Player of the Year for an outstanding season and was, on the back of that, hoping to force his way into Ireland coach Joe Schmidt's World Cup plans.

However, McCloskey (26), also named in the PRO14's Dream Team, has been left out of the 44-man squad named for the training camps that begin next month.

Instead, experienced centres Bundee Aki, Robbie Henshaw and Garry Ringrose are joined by Chris Farrell and Rory Scannell.

While the Ireland coach has left the door open for 'one or two' players to join the panel at a later date, it's notable that Leinster pair Sean O'Brien and Dan Leavy were name-checked as 'unavailable through injury' - a courtesy not given to Ulster's Will Addison.

As if it all wasn't enough to spoil McCloskey's day, he's only gone and added insult to his own injury:

If he could laugh about the unfortunate situation, plenty of Ulster fans and other interested onlookers were taking umbrage with Schmidt's squad on his behalf.

Sign In

Former Ulster player Mark Best said it was 'mental' that McCloskey could be omitted while the decision was branded an 'absolute disgrace' by supporter Ian Frizzell.

Reporter Paul Williams said he was 'miffed' and pointed out that Ulster's star man would be 'perfect' for the World Cup panel while the South Wales URSC asked "What does @Stuart_Mc12 have to do?"

"Stuart McCloskey good enough for the PRO 14 team of the year not good enough for a 44 man Ireland training squad," questioned Chris McCann and Dylan Carleton pointed out it was 'odd' before 'madness' was added by Adam James to the list of words being used to describe the situation.

Plenty more fans have been less surprised by the decision, although that's not to say they necessarily agree with it.

"(Joe Schmidt) doesn’t fancy him as a player," claimed 'Irv the Swerve' on Twitter. "He’s behind (Robbie Henshaw) and (Bundee Aki) at 12. (Joe Schmidt) doesn’t see him as versatile for covering 13.

"(McCloskey) needs a change of ire coach to get another crack. He deserves it. He’s been class for two seasons. Fully anticipate a great season ahead with a developing Ulster attack."

Colin McBride, meanwhile, was looking for the positives from a selfishly Ulster point of view: "Has always been clear Schmidt doesn't rate him. I'm not going to complain though as I'd rather him pre-seasoning with Ulster than kicking his heels in Ireland camp with a slim chance of getting in the 31 man squad. I think similarly with Cooney."

There has been, it must be said, the odd dissenting voice from amongst the Ulster support. Those include Simon Martin, who said: "Is he really better than Henshaw or Aki? He is very effective for Ulster however on limited Ireland chances hasn’t really shown it."

Looking away from McCloskey's exploits on the pitch, our man Jonathan Bradley had an alternative reason why McCloskey should, in fact, have got the call-up:

Whatever the reason, it seems like McCloskey has been a loser in the game of World Cup squad selection.

And while Ulster fans will feel aggrieved on their player's behalf, Joe Schmidt could rightly suggest that his success in the role to date merits the benefit of the doubt on these kinds of decisions.

Belfast Telegraph Digital


From Belfast Telegraph